| ||||||||||||||
COUNTERPOINT:Tsunami Aid: Not Theirs to Give
This won’t seem the appropriate time to point this out, but the money President George W. Bush is generously promising to deliver to the tsunami victims is not his to give. I don’t know exactly what you call someone who freely gives out other people’s money, but “generous” is not the word. Presumptuous, maybe. President Bush has no proper authority to send even a penny to the victims. On the other hand, the American people, individually, have every authority to send as much of their own money as they wish. They started doing so the moment they grasped the immensity of the disaster. Undoubtedly, they would do more if government weren’t doing it for them. They’d also have more money with which to be generous if government at all levels didn’t take so much of their incomes.
As for the President’s alleged authority, where does it come from? There is nothing in the Constitution that delegates to the president or the Congress the power to send the taxpayers’ money to domestic victims of natural disasters, much less to foreign victims. If anyone disagrees, let him put his finger on the provision. The powers delegated to Congress are found in Article I, Section 8. The first clause states that Congress’s power to tax is confined to these purposes: “to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States.” The preamble to the Constitution sets out the purpose of the document: “establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity.” I submit that helping the victims of tidal waves falls under none of those purposes. Earlier presidents understood this. James Madison and Grover Cleveland, among others, vetoed bills appropriating money to disaster victims on the grounds that such acts were not authorized by the basic law of the land. If you want to understand how far we have strayed from the founding philosophy, imagine a President today vetoing such a bill while quoting Madison or Cleveland. (In four years of prodigious profligacy, President Bush couldn’t find one bill worthy of his veto pen.) So let’s forget the Constitution and look at morality unadorned. By what standard is it permissible for government officials to take money from you in order to give it to someone else? Frédéric Bastiat, the great 19-century champion of freedom, rightly called that “legal plunder.” Could it be anything else?
The principle does not change simply because the intended recipients are suffering. That is a matter for the owners of income. Generosity in the face of horrible misfortune is undoubtedly a virtue. Benevolence is a natural consequence of rational self-interest. But there is no proper government role here. Forced generosity and benevolence are contradictions in terms. It is outrageous that political hacks outside the United States, including the ones at the buffoonish United Nations, feel justified in criticizing the US government for not giving enough money. It’s even more outrageous that President Bush went on the defensive and said he would increase the amount. It goes to show that America’s political misleaders know as little about the American founding philosophy as the heads of other states do. How pathetic. Sheldon Richman is senior fellow at The Future of Freedom Foundation, author of Tethered Citizens: Time to Repeal the Welfare State, and editor of The Freeman magazine.
Copyright © 2005 The Baltimore Chronicle.
All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent. This story was published on January 9, 2005. |
Local News & Opinion
Travel
Books, Arts & Education
Letters
Ref. : Letters to the editor Open Letters: 08.16 Out Damn Blot: A Letter to Colin Powell Health & Environment
08.14 The End of Cheap Oil: The Future is Now Media Watching
09.06 McCain-Palin: 'Phonies Squared' 08.31 Lady and the Gramp: The Sinister Diversion of the Palin Selection 08.28 Media Cheer Biden Choice 08.27 War With Russia Is On The Agenda 08.26 Appalling "New Look" for The Sun Signals Abdication of Journalistic Standards 08.21 Mixed Truth of the Russia-Georgia War 08.16 John McCain's Party of Hate 08.15 Corporate Media Bashes New Chavez Enabling Law Decrees 08.15 Georgia/Russia Conflict Forced Into Cold War Frame 08.13 WPost and the Great Disconnect 08.12 WPost Admits Bungling Obama Quote US Politics, Policy & Culture
09.06 Palin's 'Trooper-gate' Cover-up 09.06 Surge Protectors: Obama Embraces Bush-McCain Spin on Iraq 09.05 The Things They Left Behind (or Didn’t Remind You About) 09.05 Going on an Imperial Bender 09.05 Meet the Truth-Challenged GOP Vice Presidential Candidate: Sure A. Pallin' 09.04 The Anti-Obama Hate-Fest 09.04 Palin's 'Reformer' Myth 09.03 Did Palin Family Feud Affect Troopers? 09.02 Palin's Trouble with the Police 09.01 Minnesota Monster Mash: Police-State Zombies in a Dead Republic 08.31 Of All the Reasons McCain’s Palin Pick is Awful, Evidence of Her Abuse of Power is the Worst 08.30 McCain VP Pick Has History of Clashes 08.29 Great Speech, Big Questions, and a Curve Ball from McCain 08.28 Tongue of Flame: A Speech Presaging Endless War 08.28 Biden, Obama and The Blood-Dimmed Tide 08.28 Foreign Policy and National Security Are Not the Same Thing 08.27 Judge Rebuffs White House Immunity 08.27 What a McCain Victory Would Mean 08.22 Maybe We Should Just Hope the Republicans Win This Thing... 08.22 Loserville - Obama moves right 08.21 McCain's Ties to Neocon Hard Lines 08.21 Peace Mom v. Guardian of Power 08.20 Are You Ready For Nuclear War? 08.19 A Book Written to Defeat Obama 08.19 McCain's 'Cone of Silence' Caper 08.14 Is Perpetual War Our Future? 08.12 5 Years After Blackout, Power Grid Still in 'Dire Straits' 08.12 Olympic Shame 08.12 Thinking About Intermissions 08.11 ‘Medaling’ With Free Speech at the Olympics 08.11 Targeting Immigrants - The Largest Ever US ICE Raid US High Crimes & Misdemeanors
09.05 The real ‘Wrecking Crew’ -- not “conservatives,” but neoconservatives 09.05 Work of Evil: Beyond the Worst-Case Scenario in Somalia 09.04 Rebel Yell: Resistance and Renaissance in the Age of Terror 09.04 Katrina Redux 08.25 The Smash of Civilizations 08.22 Priming the Pump With Missile Defense: Empty Gestures Full of Blood 08.20 Musharraf, Not Bush, Follows Nixon 08.18 Fear, Procurement, Profit: Permanent War and the American Way 08.17 This Time, the World Is Not Buying It 08.15 'Imminent' Threats Should Be a Belli Laugh Economics & Business
International
09.03 Putin's Ruthless Gambit 09.01 Stoking Tensions, Risking Confrontation: A High Stakes US Gamble with Russia 08.28 Bush Escalates Tensions with Russia 08.28 Torture As Official Israeli Policy 08.25 Thinking About Cement 08.25 Reinventing the Evil Empire 08.18 Blockades: Acts of War 08.17 Rice’s Recipe for Duck Soup 08.14 The Lawless Roads: Bluster in Georgia, Rank Tyranny at Home 08.14 Marching Through Georgia V: U.S. Forces Moving Into Putin's Powderkeg 08.14 Marching Through Georgia IV: The Butt Thumper and the Bear 08.13 Using Georgia to Target Russia 08.12 From Stupid to Moronic to Evil 08.11 Marching Through Georgia III: Reality's Rout and Cheney's Viagra 08.11 Marching Through Georgia II: The Kremlin Surge We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.
|
| ||||||||||||