Newspaper logo  
 
 
   Finding a way around Right-wing News Control

MEDIA CRITICISM:

Finding a way around Right-wing News Control

by Marc Cherbonnier

The objective of scripted news is to reinforce what is said over and over to make it more a "fact." But what if such "facts" are lies, what then? That is called brainwashing. They are brainwashing you.
Given that "news" from commercial outlets is focused ever more on increasing numbers of listeners to reap greater profit from ads, their "news" has changed to become something else. Witness the rumor-driven and repetitive soap operas of Gary Condit, Elian Gonzales, Richard Jewel, Bill Clinton and Monica Lewinski, OJ Simpson, etc. Commercial news with its distortions, in the opinion of many of us, should more accurately be called "Ad-News" (which might also stand for ad-nauseam news). Ad-News doesn't have time for real news, like the genocide of a million people in Rwanda. Instead, commercial networks would rather gossip endlessly about 'that stain' on Monica's blue dress.

Right-wing Media Dominance
Ad-News is also politically right-wing warped. That orientation is not so much explained by the popularity of right-wing content (there's nothing else broadcast to compare it with!) as it is by the outright change in media ownership and/or editorial control. This change-over from predominantly left-wing to right-wing news-anchors and talk-show hosts--and guests, too--is now protected by Republican-controlled House and Senate Communication oversight committees and by the FCC itself, since committee and FCC approvals are required for media ownership changes.

The sentiments of said Republican "leadership" was recently proven by their ignoring what should have been overwhelming citizen letter-writing and opinion polls against greater ownership by media conglomerates. Instead, Republicans approved what their media "campaign donation friends" paid them for. With this change, predominantly right-wing conglomerates (Time Warner, Viacom, GE & Microsoft, Clear Channel, and News Corp.) can own more networks and broadcast their special ad-news (and primitive evangelical programming) into more cities.

Scripting the News
You may have also noticed there has been increasing similarity between Ad-News programs on a given day, even down to their saying exactly the same phrases on a topic. That's because many celebrity pundits read the same scripts--or talking points--as supplied to them from the RNC and the Heritage Foundation. (The DNC puts scripts out too, but they are ignored because the media are who they are.) "The Daily Howler," a remarkable website by Bob Somerby (from here in Baltimore, another unheralded celebrity in our midst), provides excellent coverage of this now-standard practice among the the Washington press corp. [See this "Howler" as an illustrative example]

The objective of scripted news is to reinforce what is said over and over to make it more a "fact." But what if such "facts" are lies, what then? That is called brainwashing. They are brainwashing you.

It's time to bring back Fairness Doctrine principles!
"This can't be," you may exclaim. "What of the Fairness Doctrine?" Well, there used to be one. The FCC's Fairness Doctrine was enforced (by a committee of presidential appointees) from 1949 until 1987 to require broadcasters, as a condition of getting their licenses from the FCC, to cover controversial issues in their community, and to do so by offering some balancing views. It did not require equal time for opposing views. It merely prevented a station from day after day presenting a single view without airing opposing views (like today's Fox News Channel). Reagan appointed some friends to the Fairness Doctrine enforcement committee, and, in 1987, they voted to disband themselves, saying the rapid expansion in cable and satellite networks would naturally ensure all viewpoints would be aired. Obviously that assumption has been proven wrong.

De-fanging PBS
It gets worse. During the '90s the Republican-led congress reduced public-funding of PBS, forcing it to compete with commercial networks for corporate advertising to survive. This has caused editorial 'softening' of PBS news coverage to avoid losing current or potential corporate ad sponsors. [Ref. F.A.I.R. Exposes Advertiser Influence]

Finding a way around Right-wing Censorship
In frustration to the tightening web of news control, and to circumvent congressional and FCC disapproval, Al Gore recently tried to acquire French-owned Vivendi Universal. Its value was its trained and ready staff of professionals and (limited) cable outlets. But last week Al's deal stalled (and perhaps failed) because a financial backer dropped out. [Ref. Gore TV Deal Is Stalled At The 11th Hour; Major Investor Pulls Out]

Al may not have been thinking about using PBS to carry his network's news programming, but perhaps he should. PBS news hasn't yet become as bad as Ad-News. Therefore, since the non-right are handicapped in obtaining media ownership, PBS--though editorially muted to compete for ad sponsors--is perhaps the only broadcast outlet possible for expanding journalistically professional news, a.k.a. Real News.

It would appear possible that a professional group, perhaps international, could be organized and dedicated to the production of a 24-7 suite of Real-News programs to rival the warped Ad-News outlets. The Real-News programs could be syndicated singly or as a group to public broadcasting systems world-wide, as the content quality merits.

There is no reason to presume Real-News would have lower ratings than Ad-News. Real-News is not inherently more boring than Ad-News: quite the opposite, it could be riveting if the awesome raw detail of what is actually happening were revealed--like CNN was in the very beginning. And further, for discussion programs, you could really spice things up with attractive non-gas-bag celebrities and appearances by academics and other professionals long denied access to presenting ideas directly to the public. It could be a thrilling venue if done right.

Addendum re. sustaining revenue (4/14): Ideally, advertising on Real-News should be infrequent, entertaining and educational infomercials.


Copyright © 2004 The Baltimore Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

This story was published on April 13, 2004.
   
Local News & Opinion
Travel
Books, Arts & Education
Letters

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Open Letters:

08.16 Out Damn Blot: A Letter to Colin Powell

Health & Environment

08.14 The End of Cheap Oil: The Future is Now

Media Watching

09.06 McCain-Palin: 'Phonies Squared'

08.31 Lady and the Gramp: The Sinister Diversion of the Palin Selection

08.28 Media Cheer Biden Choice

08.27 War With Russia Is On The Agenda

08.26 Appalling "New Look" for The Sun Signals Abdication of Journalistic Standards

08.21 Mixed Truth of the Russia-Georgia War

08.16 John McCain's Party of Hate

08.15 Corporate Media Bashes New Chavez Enabling Law Decrees

08.15 Georgia/Russia Conflict Forced Into Cold War Frame

08.13 WPost and the Great Disconnect

08.12 WPost Admits Bungling Obama Quote

US Politics, Policy & Culture

09.06 Palin's 'Trooper-gate' Cover-up

09.06 Surge Protectors: Obama Embraces Bush-McCain Spin on Iraq

09.05 The Things They Left Behind (or Didn’t Remind You About)

09.05 Going on an Imperial Bender

09.05 Meet the Truth-Challenged GOP Vice Presidential Candidate: Sure A. Pallin'

09.04 The Anti-Obama Hate-Fest

09.04 Palin's 'Reformer' Myth

09.03 Did Palin Family Feud Affect Troopers?

09.02 Palin's Trouble with the Police

09.01 Minnesota Monster Mash: Police-State Zombies in a Dead Republic

08.31 Of All the Reasons McCain’s Palin Pick is Awful, Evidence of Her Abuse of Power is the Worst

08.30 McCain VP Pick Has History of Clashes

08.29 Great Speech, Big Questions, and a Curve Ball from McCain

08.28 Tongue of Flame: A Speech Presaging Endless War

08.28 Biden, Obama and The Blood-Dimmed Tide

08.28 Foreign Policy and National Security Are Not the Same Thing

08.27 Judge Rebuffs White House Immunity

08.27 What a McCain Victory Would Mean

08.22 Maybe We Should Just Hope the Republicans Win This Thing...

08.22 Loserville - Obama moves right

08.21 McCain's Ties to Neocon Hard Lines

08.21 Peace Mom v. Guardian of Power

08.20 Are You Ready For Nuclear War?

08.19 A Book Written to Defeat Obama

08.19 McCain's 'Cone of Silence' Caper

08.14 Is Perpetual War Our Future?

08.12 5 Years After Blackout, Power Grid Still in 'Dire Straits'

08.12 Olympic Shame

08.12 Thinking About Intermissions

08.11 ‘Medaling’ With Free Speech at the Olympics

08.11 Targeting Immigrants - The Largest Ever US ICE Raid

US “High Crimes” & Misdemeanors

09.05 The real ‘Wrecking Crew’ -- not “conservatives,” but neoconservatives

09.05 Work of Evil: Beyond the Worst-Case Scenario in Somalia

09.04 Rebel Yell: Resistance and Renaissance in the Age of Terror

09.04 Katrina Redux

08.25 The Smash of Civilizations

08.22 Priming the Pump With Missile Defense: Empty Gestures Full of Blood

08.20 Musharraf, Not Bush, Follows Nixon

08.18 Fear, Procurement, Profit: Permanent War and the American Way

08.17 This Time, the World Is Not Buying It

08.15 'Imminent' Threats Should Be a Belli Laugh

Economics & Business
International

09.03 Putin's Ruthless Gambit

09.01 Stoking Tensions, Risking Confrontation: A High Stakes US Gamble with Russia

08.28 Bush Escalates Tensions with Russia

08.28 Torture As Official Israeli Policy

08.25 Thinking About Cement

08.25 Reinventing the Evil Empire

08.18 Blockades: Acts of War

08.17 Rice’s Recipe for Duck Soup

08.14 The Lawless Roads: Bluster in Georgia, Rank Tyranny at Home

08.14 Marching Through Georgia V: U.S. Forces Moving Into Putin's Powderkeg

08.14 Marching Through Georgia IV: The Butt Thumper and the Bear

08.13 Using Georgia to Target Russia

08.12 From Stupid to Moronic to Evil

08.11 Marching Through Georgia III: Reality's Rout and Cheney's Viagra

08.11 Marching Through Georgia II: The Kremlin Surge

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.
Google
This site Web
 

Public Service Ads:
Verifiable Voting in Maryland