Newspaper logo  
 
 
  The Fraud of Physician-Assisted Suicide

SPEAKING OUT:

The Fraud of Physician-Assisted Suicide

by Sheldon Richman

How can there be "death with dignity" when the patient must humbly petition the doctors, then meekly wait for a unanimous ruling?
Freedom is so little understood in this "land of the free" that it is often confused with its opposite. Case in point: Oregon's 1994 Death With Dignity Act, which a federal appeals court recently shielded from attack by US Attorney General John Ashcroft.

The law permits what has come to be known as physician-assisted suicide. It and the appellate ruling have been hailed as victories for patient autonomy and the right to commit suicide. Indeed, the New York Times, in praising the ruling, editorialized. "The voters of Oregon acted with great humanity when they decided to allow terminally ill people to determine when they have suffered enough."

But did the voters really do that? A closer look at the law shows they did not.

In fact the law lets a patient who is expected to die within six months ask his doctor for lethal drugs. The doctor can say no, as he has every right to do. But since a patient cannot end his own life without the doctor's consent, the law is no milestone on the road to individual freedom.

What happens when a patient makes such a request of his doctor? The state's requirements are "stringent," according to Dr. Peter Goodwin, a long-time family physician and an emeritus associate professor in the Department of Family Medicine at Oregon Health and Science University. They include, Goodwin writes, "the attending physician's diagnosis/prognosis and determination that the patient is informed, capable and acting voluntarily."

Note that the attending physician must be convinced that the patient knows what he's doing. Whether or not you think doctors have a special ability to see the absence of volition in an action (I don't), this requirement is hardly consistent with "allow[ing] terminally ill people to determine when they have suffered enough."

But there's more. The law states, "A consulting physician must examine the patient and the medical records and concur with the attending physician's diagnosis/prognosis and assessment of the patient."

Dr. Goodwin comments: "If the attending physician or the consulting physician thinks the patient may suffer from a psychological disorder causing impaired judgment, the physician must refer the patient for evaluation and counseling. No medication may be prescribed unless it is certain the patient's judgment is not impaired" (emphasis added).

Although these requirements are called "stringent," they are actually elastic and stacked against the patient. What terminally ill patient in great pain could not be said to have impaired judgment? What's the difference between a judgment that's impaired and one that clashes with the doctor's? In a conflict between a patient who sees no better future and wants to die and a physician (perhaps supported by the patient's family) who sees the future differently, who will prevail? The doctor, of course. Yet the law is considered a blow for patient autonomy. How can there be "death with dignity" when the patient must humbly petition the doctors, then meekly wait for a unanimous ruling?

Whatever one thinks of the legal merits of Attorney General Ashcroft's attempt to use federal anti-drug laws to thwart Oregon's voters, physician-assisted suicide is a fraud. As Dr. Thomas Szasz writes in his book Fatal Freedom: The Ethics and Politics of Suicide, "The term 'physician-assisted suicide' [PAS] is intrinsically mendacious. The physician is the principal, not the assistant. In the normal use of the English language, the person who assists another is the subordinate; the person whom he assists is his superior.... However, the physician engaging in PAS is superior to the patient: He determines who qualifies for the 'treatment' and prescribes the drug for it."

In other words, the Oregon law has nothing to do with the freedom of the individual and everything to do with the power of doctors. If freedom were the concern, we would simply repeal the drug and prescription laws, and recognize each adult's right to buy any kind of drugs.

Why empower doctors? Suicide isn't a medical issue. It's a moral issue.


Sheldon Richman is senior fellow at The Future of Freedom Foundation (fff.org) in Fairfax, Va., author of Tethered Citizens: Time to Repeal the Welfare State, and editor of The Freeman magazine.


Copyright © 2004 The Baltimore Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

This story was published on June 28, 2004.
 
Local News & Opinion

05.07 YouthWorks Campaign Needs Support for Summer Jobs

Books, Art & Entertainment

05.13 New Buchanan Book: Anglo-American Ascendancy Lost in Unnecessary Wars

04.30 A Litany of Horrors

04.17 Peter Hallward's "Damming the Flood" (Part II)

Letters

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Health & Environment

05.12 The World above 350 ppm CO2

04.28 Green Scare State Terrorism

04.21 Hunger Plagues Haiti and the World

04.16 WORLD FACING HUGE NEW CHALLENGE ON FOOD FRONT

Ref. : Single-Payer FAQ

Ref. : Environmental Health News

Ref. : Sundance Channel's THE GREEN

Ref. : What is Global Warming, and what can citizens do about it?

Ref. : Global Warming Links

Ref. : Health & Nutrition Links

Media Watching

05.06 US Media Trivializes Campaign 2008

05.06 Death's Factotum: Michael Gordon and the Times Pour Pentagon Poison into Nation's Ear

05.05 TV News Blackout on Pentagon Pundits

05.05 Color-Coded: Jeremiah Wright and the Real Deal on Race

05.02 The Right's America-Hating Preacher

04.23 Pentagon Pundits

04.22 US News Media's Latest Disgrace

04.18 ABC's Debate Debacle

04.16 Reprising the Genocidal Fury of Thomas Friedman

US Politics, Policy & Culture

05.14 Bush Operative Pushes Voter-ID Law

05.13 Hillary Clinton, John McCain and the "Stupid" Vote

05.13 McCain and the 'Unitary Executive'

05.09 The Democratic Presidential Race: A View from Pennsylvania

05.08 Serving the System: Corporate Control of U.S. Would Continue Under Obama

05.06 A Republican for Barack

05.05 Thinking About Voter Registrations

05.05 'Beware the Terrible Simplifiers'

05.01 U.S. Military Coordinated Day Of Prayer Events With Christian Right Group

04.30 John McCain Won’t Be Looking for the Union Label

04.30 Put Him Out With the Pastor!

04.25 Clinton Courted Racists in the Pennsylvania Primary

04.24 Groundbreaking Book Documents Widespread Election Fraud; Warns Elections Vulnerable to Theft

04.24 Triviamongering in the U.S. presidential race

04.24 Campaign 1988 Lives!

04.23 Hillary Clinton's Monstrous Threat

04.21 Brilliant Disguise: Bush Torture, Obama and The Boss

04.19 The Clintons, Triangulating with China

04.18 American Hegemony Is Not Guaranteed

04.18 Are the Clintons Playing Joe McCarthy?

04.17 The Weather Underground 'Theme'

US “High Crimes” & Incompetence

05.14 Falling Cedars: Fomenting War in Lebanon -- and Beyond

05.12 Armed Truce: Surging Into Slaughter on Sadr City's Jerusalem Street

05.10 Lost E-Mails Obscure 'Plame-gate'

05.09 Fallujah Revisited: Bush, Petraeus Prepare 'Cleansing' of Sadr City

05.09 Shoot, Kill, Lie, Repeat: America's New Moral Universe

05.07 Willing Executioners: America's Bipartisan Atrocity Deepens in Somalia

05.05 The Terror Master: Bush Orders Covert 'Surge' Against Iran, with Dem Support

05.01 American and Israeli War Crimes: Same Atrocities, Different Responses

04.30 Halliburton Bribe Case Haunts Cheney

04.29 Getting Over Scalia

04.29 The Iraq War Morphs Into The Iranian War

04.28 The Torture Election

04.28 The Clock is Ticking for A US Attack on Iran

04.28 The Bush Team's Geneva Hypocrisy

04.25 New Terror War Atrocity: Beheading the Innocent for Bush in Somalia

04.23 Glorious Fruits of the War for Civilization

04.22 VA Tried to Conceal Extent of Attempted Veteran Suicides, Email Shows

04.21 What About the War, Benedict?

04.18 Updating Sami Al-Arian - His Ordeal Continues

04.16 Would Obama Hold Bush Accountable?

Economics & Business

05.12 Thinking About Strategies

05.08 Portrait of an Oil-Addicted Former Superpower

04.28 Thinking About Subtleties

04.23 The Oil Vice

04.22 The US Economy and the Costs of War

04.21 Thinking About Shakiness

International

05.12 Disturbing Stirrings - Ratcheting Up For War on Iran

05.05 Sixty Years of Palestinian Displacement, Occupation and Suffering

05.02 Feeding Moloch: Last Barriers to War on Iran Come Down

05.01 The Iranian Chessboard

05.01 Blood Diamonds, Blood Oil and Blood Food

05.01 Denying Palestinians Free Movement in the West Bank

04.30 The Ignored Lessons on the Stupidity of War

04.24 Breaking the Silence - Israeli Soldiers Speak

04.23 What the Iraq War is about

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.
Google
This site Web
 

Public Service Ads:
Verifiable Voting in Maryland