Newspaper logo  
 
 
  The Fraud of Physician-Assisted Suicide

SPEAKING OUT:

The Fraud of Physician-Assisted Suicide

by Sheldon Richman

How can there be "death with dignity" when the patient must humbly petition the doctors, then meekly wait for a unanimous ruling?
Freedom is so little understood in this "land of the free" that it is often confused with its opposite. Case in point: Oregon's 1994 Death With Dignity Act, which a federal appeals court recently shielded from attack by US Attorney General John Ashcroft.

The law permits what has come to be known as physician-assisted suicide. It and the appellate ruling have been hailed as victories for patient autonomy and the right to commit suicide. Indeed, the New York Times, in praising the ruling, editorialized. "The voters of Oregon acted with great humanity when they decided to allow terminally ill people to determine when they have suffered enough."

But did the voters really do that? A closer look at the law shows they did not.

In fact the law lets a patient who is expected to die within six months ask his doctor for lethal drugs. The doctor can say no, as he has every right to do. But since a patient cannot end his own life without the doctor's consent, the law is no milestone on the road to individual freedom.

What happens when a patient makes such a request of his doctor? The state's requirements are "stringent," according to Dr. Peter Goodwin, a long-time family physician and an emeritus associate professor in the Department of Family Medicine at Oregon Health and Science University. They include, Goodwin writes, "the attending physician's diagnosis/prognosis and determination that the patient is informed, capable and acting voluntarily."

Note that the attending physician must be convinced that the patient knows what he's doing. Whether or not you think doctors have a special ability to see the absence of volition in an action (I don't), this requirement is hardly consistent with "allow[ing] terminally ill people to determine when they have suffered enough."

But there's more. The law states, "A consulting physician must examine the patient and the medical records and concur with the attending physician's diagnosis/prognosis and assessment of the patient."

Dr. Goodwin comments: "If the attending physician or the consulting physician thinks the patient may suffer from a psychological disorder causing impaired judgment, the physician must refer the patient for evaluation and counseling. No medication may be prescribed unless it is certain the patient's judgment is not impaired" (emphasis added).

Although these requirements are called "stringent," they are actually elastic and stacked against the patient. What terminally ill patient in great pain could not be said to have impaired judgment? What's the difference between a judgment that's impaired and one that clashes with the doctor's? In a conflict between a patient who sees no better future and wants to die and a physician (perhaps supported by the patient's family) who sees the future differently, who will prevail? The doctor, of course. Yet the law is considered a blow for patient autonomy. How can there be "death with dignity" when the patient must humbly petition the doctors, then meekly wait for a unanimous ruling?

Whatever one thinks of the legal merits of Attorney General Ashcroft's attempt to use federal anti-drug laws to thwart Oregon's voters, physician-assisted suicide is a fraud. As Dr. Thomas Szasz writes in his book Fatal Freedom: The Ethics and Politics of Suicide, "The term 'physician-assisted suicide' [PAS] is intrinsically mendacious. The physician is the principal, not the assistant. In the normal use of the English language, the person who assists another is the subordinate; the person whom he assists is his superior.... However, the physician engaging in PAS is superior to the patient: He determines who qualifies for the 'treatment' and prescribes the drug for it."

In other words, the Oregon law has nothing to do with the freedom of the individual and everything to do with the power of doctors. If freedom were the concern, we would simply repeal the drug and prescription laws, and recognize each adult's right to buy any kind of drugs.

Why empower doctors? Suicide isn't a medical issue. It's a moral issue.


Sheldon Richman is senior fellow at The Future of Freedom Foundation (fff.org) in Fairfax, Va., author of Tethered Citizens: Time to Repeal the Welfare State, and editor of The Freeman magazine.


Copyright © 2004 The Baltimore Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

This story was published on June 28, 2004.
 
Local Gov’t Stories, Events

04.30 Freddie Gray's housing complex still plagued by poor conditions and abuse

Ref. : Civic Events

Ref. : Arts & Education Events

Ref. : Public Service Notices

Travel
Books, Films, Arts & Education

05.02 People love Chris Packham because he isn’t afraid to ruffle feathers

Letters

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Health Care & Environment

05.02 The Astonishing Creativity of Your Genes

05.02 Armed guards at India's dams as drought grips country

05.02 The innovators: desalination unit brings clean water on wheels

04.30 Surprise, the pundits were wrong: poll shows huge support for Leap Manifesto

04.30 Daytime cooking ban in India as heatwave claims 300 lives

04.30 Obama administration warns of ‘climate refugees’ due to rapid Arctic warming

04.29 Greens are often critical of the status quo. No wonder the police monitor us

04.29 Rowan Williams calls on Cambridge University to divest from fossil fuels

04.29 It's time to end juvenile solitary confinement, once and for all

04.29 Obama administration urges states to curb use of solitary confinement

News Media Matters

Daily: FAIR Blog
The Daily Howler

US Politics, Policy & 'Culture'

05.02 Sam Brownback gutted Kansas: How America’s worst governor and an ultra-conservative ideology wrecked an entire state

05.02 Bill Moyers in Conversation: Eddie Glaude Jr. on America’s Racial ‘Value Gap’ [audio clip]

05.02 Bernie Sanders vows a contested convention despite 'tough road' ahead

05.01 'Mad as hell' middle class independents shape presidential race on their terms

05.01 A New Way to Map the Spread and Decline of Slavery in the U.S. [animated graphic]

05.01 Clintonism screwed the Democrats: How Bill, Hillary and the Democratic Leadership Council gutted progressivism

05.01 'You're a sinner': how a Mormon university shames rape victims

04.30 Story of cities #29: Los Angeles and the 'great American streetcar scandal'

04.30 Donald Trump forced from his motorcade amid chaotic protests at California convention

Justice Matters

05.02 The movement to end mass incarceration is still too weak to win big [private prisons must be kept at near-full occupancy by contract, so...]

04.30 Louisiana prisoner freed after 41 years of controversial sentence

High Crimes?

04.30 How the car industry trumped banking for sociopathic corporate behaviour

Economics, Crony Capitalism

05.02 Greenpeace Leak Exposes Big EU-US Rifts, US Thuggishness, in TTIP “Trade” Negotiations

05.02 TTIP Documents Revealed

05.01 Buffett Says Derivatives ‘Time Bomb’ May Elude Auditors' Reviews

04.29 Trump, Cruz aides advised Guatemalan candidate vowing televised executions

04.29 Obama: Republican candidates' economic policies are pure 'fantasy'

04.29 Sluggish US growth forms part of a worrying global trend

International

05.02 The End of American Iraq: Poor Shiites invade Parliament over corrupt Spoils System [Like Red states only contracting business with Red contractors]

05.02 The reluctance of Joseph Kabila to cede power could push Congo to the brink

05.01 How Hyperconnected Cities Are Taking Over the World

05.01 Japan's Growing Poverty Defies Glib Explanations

05.01 Dozens of Syrians forced into sexual slavery in derelict Lebanese house

05.01 'Anyone could become a target’: wave of Islamist killings hits Bangladesh

05.01 Humanoid diving robot hunts for sunken treasure in French shipwreck

05.01 Baghdad state of emergency declared after protesters storm parliament

05.01 ‘We’ve had massacres all week’: Aleppo on fire again as Assad consigns ceasefire to history

04.30 President Trump fills world leaders with fear: 'It's gone from funny to really scary'

04.30 End of the car age: how cities are outgrowing the automobile

04.30 'You are left with no choice but to leave' – your stories of long-term gentrification

04.30 Los Angeles to get on-demand 'driverless buses'

04.30 Netherlands to hand out iodine pills in case of nuclear accident

04.30 China refuses US carrier permission for port call in Hong Kong harbour

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.

You can also mail a check to:
Baltimore News Network, Inc.
P.O. Box 42581
Baltimore, MD 21284-2581
Google
This site Web


Public Service Ads: