Newspaper logo  
 
 
  The Government You Deserve

SPEAKING OUT:

The Government You Deserve

by John Chuckman

The same dead certainty and implicit threat of Bush and Buchanan are, after all, the underlying message of so much of the TV advertising in which Americans are immersed day and night: use our product or risk the torments of social hell.
It has been said that people pretty much get the government they deserve. There is more than a little justice in the observation.

Pat Buchanan, long my choice as symbol for all that is wrong with America, has given a last-minute endorsement to George Bush's re-election. One is tempted to class his words, qualified as they are, with the grovelings of John McCain at Bush rallies.

After spending a couple of years successfully peddling columns attacking Bush for repeating the bloody stupidity of Vietnam, Pat has come to the conclusion that Bush isn't so bad after all. He says that while Bush is wrong on the war, he is right on just about everything else.

I suppose Pat's list of things that are right with Bush includes Jehovah's receiving a seat on the National Security Council, some of the Patriot Act's finer points on human rights, sending individuals secretly to places like Syria or Egypt to be tortured, insulting and alienating friends and allies, squandering a hundred billion dollars without managing so much as a patch-up of Iraq's smashed infrastructure, and laughing off world environmental threats far more deadly than anything dreamed of by terrorists.

Pat perfectly represents America's noisy, pointless "culture of complaint," something which mimics the effects of a bad gene pool, endowing America with ridiculous trash like Crossfire or Rush Limbaugh or whole networks like CNN or, indeed, the grotesque practices of its national elections.

We usually do not hear much about stolen votes in America because the two parties are satisfied with the calculation that the damage inflicted is roughly equal.

Recall Emerson's advice, "A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds." Certainly, no one can accuse Pat of consistency, foolish or otherwise. When war served his career, his rise to White House speechwriter, war was a very good thing. He defended it, or should I say he defended others being sent to it, fists flailing and lips flapping. Later, as failed presidential candidate for the re-born Know Nothing Party, being against another war provided some limited scope for still being listened to by some of the party he had opportunistically turned against.

Pat, not being an evangelical in religion, is very much one in politics. Much like Bush, but with far more showmanship, he always displays an evangelist's sputteringly obnoxious and insistent tone of certainty about what he is selling: if you don't listen to me, you're doomed to a horrible fate. The evangelical tone is common in America's politics and contributes to the massive sound and fury of its political campaigns. The same dead certainty and implicit threat are, after all, the underlying message of so much of the television advertising in which Americans are immersed day and night: use our product or risk the torments of social hell.

Pat is typical of so much of America in his efforts to claw his way to the top, embracing a bizarre distortion of William James's philosophy of pragmatism. Whatever works for our own momentary self-interest, we do, a practice which makes the moral relativism falsely-ascribed to liberals look deep by comparison. Likely, the near-absence of genuine morals now common in the commercial and political life of America is partly responsible for the resurgence of fundamentalism. Fundamentalism offers certainty where there is none and the sense of always being able to start fresh. The Puritan brand also is long associated with notions of those chosen and those not chosen, a satisfying private reflection for those who are less successful in clawing for the top.

How many Americans reflect on the stupid, needless death and destruction inflicted on Iraqis (families hiding in smashed apartments without clean water, electricity, or jobs) while driving their air-conditioned SUVs, listening to the stereo, on the way to a sale at the Crate and Barrel? Were they concerned with such things, the bloody, destructive invasion could not have happened, but, then, neither could there have been ten years of organized murder in Vietnam.

Returning to Pat's pick for president, my first thoughts on the Bush "bulge" controversy (see the wonderfully informative site, http://homepage.mac.com/c.shaw/BushBulges/PhotoAlbum15.html ) went to Shakespeare's hump-backed embodiment of evil, Richard III, but Shakespeare's character is fascinating, and of course the historical Richard, so far as we know, was a genuinely heroic figure. Bush is simply a dull man with a shrill voice. The next comparison that came to mind was a marionette, only an updated version with radio controls and servomotors instead of strings and hinges.

Only empty slogans are heard, a billion dollars' worth of slogans on television, a billion dollars obtained from the people who actually do run the country.

Whatever the best analogy, the fact that the American president wears a radio device of some kind during important meetings and national debates has been sufficiently established for people of a critical turn of mind. The revelation seems almost an over-the-top parody of what we already knew of Bush's capacities, an absurd editorial cartoon about an inadequate man walking through responsibilities he doesn't understand, leaving in his wake terrible damage to decent government and peace. Where do the voices in his earpiece come from? Lynne Cheney? The Boston Strangler? Franklin Graham? Jesus? The Wizard of Oz? All of the above?

America, you elected this plodding creature, and it appears you are about to do so again. Never mind the narrow focus on stolen votes in Florida, nasty stuff that it is. Stolen votes are an enduring part of the great chaotic noise you call national elections. Stolen votes in Texas got Lyndon Johnson's political career going, and stolen votes in Texas and Illinois put Kennedy into office. We usually do not hear much about stolen votes in America because the two parties are satisfied with the calculation that the damage inflicted is roughly equal.

Are stolen votes more contemptible than the absolutely corrupt practices of powerful politicians like Tom DeLay? Are stolen votes more contemptible than an election campaign in which the genuine issues of the day, matters of life and death, do not receive a sensible airing? Since those same great issues are ignored by most Americans between national elections, just when are they considered?

The truth is that there is no national debate in America on almost anything of genuine importance. The most narrow self-interest continues relentlessly under all the superficial noise and cheap tricks that pass for politics, and, so long as that remains the case, America will continue to kill and maim and overthrow whenever it serves the needs of clawing for more and the heat of evangelical fervor.

Only empty slogans are heard, a billion dollars' worth of slogans on television, a billion dollars obtained from the people who actually do run the country.


John Chuckman, a former chief economist for a large Canadian oil company, is a member of no political party. His articles can be found on such sites as YellowTimes, CounterPunch, SmirkingChimp, and Democrats with Spine. He encourages reader comments: chuckman@yellowtimes.org.


Copyright © 2004 The Baltimore Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

This story was published on October 27, 2004.

 
Local Gov’t Stories, Events

Ref. : Civic Events

Ref. : Arts & Education Events

Ref. : Public Service Notices

Travel
Books, Films, Arts & Education
Letters

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Health Care & Environment

04.29 Trump has it Backwards: It is Dirty Coal that’s Killing Green Jobs

04.29 Children can’t play if they can’t breathe because our air is so polluted [good government is needed]

04.29 The American people – not Big Oil – must decide our climate future

04.28 1.2 million children in the US have lead poisoning. We’re only treating half of them. [willfully ignoring children's health so the rich can get tax breaks—to be even richer—is immoral and costs much more long-term]

04.28 East coast readies for fresh climate fight as Trump eyes more offshore drilling [the Idiocracy is growing]

04.28 Air pollution plan cannot be delayed, high court tells government

04.27 Trump’s hollow promise on the opioid epidemic: GOP health plan would slash Medicaid funding for drug treatment

04.27 The Last time there was this much CO2 in the air, Florida was under Water [Trump will sell his properties before admitting to a problem]

04.26 Discovery of plastic-eating worms offers chance to finally get rid of world's growing piles of litter

04.26 People whose 'brain age' is older than their real age more likely to die early

04.25 Pollution From Canada’s Oil Sands May Be Underreported

04.25 High court orders UK government to explain clean air plan delay

04.25 Matt Damon: ‘Children are drinking water so dirty it looks like chocolate milk’

04.24 Disney, the Gap and Pepsi urged to quit US Chamber of Commerce ["Its a small world after all..." – Disney]

04.24 Why we joined the March for Science

News Media Matters

04.27 Authoritarians Like Trump Pushing Global Press Freedoms to 'Tipping Point' [stamping out inconvenient truths]

Daily: FAIR Blog
The Daily Howler

US Politics, Policy & 'Culture'

04.29 Why Are House Dems Treating 2016 Campaign Autopsy Like a Classified Document? [obsessive money focus requires compromises that kill best and most-efficient public programs and policy—and that makes the public very very angry]

04.29 Trickle Down Devastation: A Single Mom Responds to Trump’s Tax Plan

04.29 With Support Surging, Progressives Push Pelosi on Single-Payer

04.29 Watchdogs: Trump's Disastrous 100 Days Fueling "Golden Era of Activism"

04.28 'We Reject Politics of Fear': Groups Urge Congress to Build Schools, Not Wall

04.28 Red Flags as Trump Team Dodges on Tax Plan's Impact on Middle Class

04.28 For First Time Ever, Majority of House Dems Support 'Medicare-for-All' Bill

04.28 Bernie Sanders takes aim at Trump on climate ahead of march in DC

04.28 Failing the ‘Mnuchin Test’

04.28 America, From Exceptionalism to Nihilism

04.27 4 Ways Trump's Tax Plan Will Make the Trumps Even Richer

04.27 The Trump family’s massive grift: Who cares about policy? As a business and branding venture, this presidency is going swell

04.27 Can Progressives Mobilize to Save the Middle Class?

04.27 A Comprehensive Guide to Donald Trump’s Tax Proposal

04.27 Trump under fire over 'huge tax cut for the rich' [1:03 video]

Justice Matters

04.27 10 signs Trump’s top Homeland Security cop wants to drag America into a paranoid apocalyptic police state

High Crimes?

04.29 Cruelty or keeping it in the family? What I learned from India's slaveholders

Economics, Crony Capitalism

04.27 Digital Rights Groups Vow to Fight FCC Chair's Net Neutrality Attack "Tooth and Nail"

04.27 Brazilians fight back against corruption– with the help of a purple plug-in [we hope app is updated for corrupt politicians everywhere!]

04.26 'Truly Dumb': Why $2.4 Trillion Corporate Tax Cut Will Not Magically Pay for Itself

04.26 Why Is Congress In Such A Rush To Strip The Library Of Congress Of Oversight Powers On The Copyright Office?

04.25 The Right’s Green Awakening

04.25 Trump's Corporate Takeover Detailed 100 Days into 'For-Profit Presidency'

International

04.29 'Europe's dirty secret': officials on Chios scramble to cope with rising tensions

04.29 Brazilians sick of corrupt politicians hit the streets to protest austerity measures

04.28 40 years later, the mothers of Argentina’s 'disappeared' refuse to be silent

04.28 Europe could allow a united Ireland to join EU after Brexit

04.28 Le Pen's replacement steps down after allegedly casting doubt on Nazi gas chambers

04.27 UK should axe state pension for rich people, says OECD [the moral choice for all nations]

04.26 ‘We’re eating the Mercedes’

04.26 Turkish Airstrikes On Kurds Complicate U.S. Operations In Iraq And Syria

04.26 Ivanka Trump met with jeers in Berlin as she calls father 'champion of families'

04.26 Assad forces carried out sarin attack, say French intelligence [evidence proves Syria made the weapon, but not who used it]

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.

You can also mail a check to:
Baltimore News Network, Inc.
P.O. Box 42581
Baltimore, MD 21284-2581
Google
This site Web

Public Service Ads: