Newspaper logo  
 
 
  Misplaced Myths and Current Dangers

ANALYSIS:

Misplaced Myths and Current Dangers

by Edna Garte

...the way to fight evil is to maximize your own goodness. Throughout history however, nations have distorted these spiritual ideas into justifications for military crusades.
When I was four years old, my mother and I came across some soldiers on leave who were drunk and behaving aggressively. A little confused, I embarrassed my mother by asking, "Mummy, are those good soldiers or bad soldiers?" I had been taught that good and bad soldiers were fighting a war, and that we believed the good soldiers would win.

Now that I'm a little older, I know that life isn't that simple. Good and bad don't always line themselves up in opposing armies. Destructive forces on opposite sides of a conflict can feed each other, endangering everyone. We need to keep those forces from sending us into a panic that leaves us running to them for shelter. One cure is to look carefully at differences between myth and reality.

Myths often have kernels of truth that inspires people with their values. When they're taken literally, however, they present over-simplified pictures that defeat their own purposes.

There is a dangerous way of thinking about our current foreign policy, which has wrapped itself in an ancient religious belief.

To bring death, crippling injury, and water poisoned with human sewage to thousands of people unnecessarily, in the hope of instituting paradise, is to play God--without God's love, compassion, wisdom and information.

This idea goes back to Zoroaster (6th century BC), an Iranian philosopher who influenced Judaism, Christianity and Islam. In a nutshell, it says that Good and Evil have been in conflict throughout time. God works through the Good, which will finally win out. Paradise then will become universal.

Zoroaster believed the way to fight evil is to maximize your own goodness. Throughout history however, nations have distorted these spiritual ideas into justifications for military crusades.

In relation to Iraq, the myth goes something like this:

The war in Iraq is part of a greater struggle between good and evil. Since the evil ones all serve the same Enemy, they must be in league with each other. We have the power to destroy all of them. We also have a higher mission. If we accept the “collateral damage”, we can turn the Middle East into a garden of democracy, peace and love for America. Terror will then disappear; harmony will prevail, and oil will flow freely throughout the earth.

What's wrong with this picture?

What's wrong is what it does to reality. Saddam Hussein and Osama Bin Laden were not in league with each other; they were rivals for power. Many believe Osama was trying to provoke us into a general Middle Eastern war that would drain our resources, destroy our international influence, and leave us vulnerable to his attacks.

It is one thing to defend ourselves, and do everything we can to stop atrocities in other parts of the world. It is another to second-guess history and try to stamp out all evil in advance, thinking the final outcome will justify our actions. To bring death, crippling injury, and water poisoned with human sewage to thousands of people unnecessarily, in the hope of instituting paradise, is to play God--without God's love, compassion, wisdom and information.

We need leaders who can discern our real security needs. A president needs to distinguish between immediate threats and imagined opportunities to transform a region of the world. If we want to use myths, we’re better off going back to their essential truths. We can increase goodness by taking care of each other, and remembering that the same spirit lives in every person on earth.


Edna Garte is Professor of Humanities at Oakland Community College, in Auburn Hills, MI.


Copyright © 2004 The Baltimore Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

This story was published on November 1, 2004.

 
Local Stories, Events

Ref. : Civic Events

Ref. : Arts & Education Events

Ref. : Public Service Notices

Books, Films, Arts & Education

08.11 DeVos Ends Obama-Era Safeguards Aimed at Abuses by For-Profit Colleges [an Administration that's consistent in its predatorial immorality—helping the rich by hurting the poor and uninformed]

08.11 'Disaster Capitalism Strikes Again!': Puerto Rico's High Court Gives Green Light to Charter Schools, Vouchers [Drinking Betsy DeVos' poisoned Kool Aid]

Letters

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Health Care & Environment

08.14 As America Burns From Climate Change, Trump Officials Attend Denial Conference to Discuss Why Climate Change is Fake [stunningly stupid—killing everything to maximize fossil asset profits]

08.13  Sweltering cities  Halfway to boiling: the city at 50C

08.11 Toxic Corruption: The Chemical Industry Keeps Pulling EPA's Strings

08.11 'It's heartbreaking': Killer whale continues carrying dead calf for 'unprecedented' length of mourning [extinctions like this can be minimized if humans try...]

08.10 Banning Single-Use Plastics: Can Armenia Take Out the Trash for Good?

08.10 'Major Victory for Public Health': Court Orders Trump EPA to Ban Pesticide That Harms Kids' Brains

08.10 Jacinda Ardern says New Zealand will ban plastic bags

08.09 Solar With Storage Surges as Gas Falls

08.09 Why We Need More Women Involved in Creating Environmental Policy

08.08 Medicare for All Makes A Lot of Sense [greed trumps morality, so far...]

News Media Matters

08.13 More than 100 US newspapers plan editorials decrying Trump media attacks [do Trump's childish opinions define Truth?]

08.10 The White Nationalists Are Winning

Daily: FAIR Blog
The Daily Howler

US Politics, Policy & 'Culture'

08.14 How the House Judiciary Committee’s Makeup Will Shape Impeachment

08.14 Public Sector Workers Should Have the Right to Strike

08.14 A Change Is Gonna Come': Poll Shows Democratic Voters Like Socialism More Than Capitalism

08.12 Conservatives call for constitutional intervention last seen 230 years ago [wackos want ‘freedom’]

08.11 Confused By Emoluments? The Founding Fathers Would Have Impeached Trump in a New York Minute [Intents purposely written into “living documents” by the Founding Fathers should not be destroyed by literal strictures demanded by present-day Federalist Society judges]

08.11 The Left Is Just Getting Started

08.11 'Absolute Failure': DNC Passes Perez Resolution Reversing Ban on Donations From Fossil Fuel PACs [its amazing so many are tone-deaf/blind on these issues]

Justice Matters
High Crimes?

08.10 'Can You Imagine Living Like This?' Pregnant Woman and Toddler Among Those Killed in Israel's Latest Vicious Assault on Gaza

08.10 'We Just Bombed a SCHOOL BUS': Outrage After US-Backed Saudi Coalition Slaughters Children in Yemen

Economics, Crony Capitalism

08.12 Why Public Banks Are Suddenly Popular

08.10 Buried in the Fine Print, Trump Rule Would Give $2.5 Billion Tax Cut to Big Bank Fat Cats

08.09 Rick Gates Delivers a Public Lesson on Money Laundering and Political Corruption

International & Futurism

08.14 Israel, This Is Not Who We Are

08.13 Turkish lira crisis: central bank action fails to quell contagion fears

08.10 'A devastating scenario': Brazil sets new record for homicides at 63,880 deaths

08.09 The Guardian view on Saudi Arabia: time to back Canada

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.

You can also mail a check to:
Baltimore News Network, Inc.
P.O. Box 42581
Baltimore, MD 21284-2581
Google
This site Web

Public Service Ads: