Newspaper logo  
 
 
  Dealing in Death: Bush's FDA

COMMENTARY:

Dealing in Death: Bush's FDA

by Don Monkerud

In 2004, the FDA failed to meet 70 percent of their own benchmarks for proposed rulemaking, final deadlines and reaching decisions on petitions with deadly consequences.
After years of protecting the pubic from dangerous food and drugs, the FDA has embarked on a new path to protect corporate profits at all costs. Even death is no obstacle.

The stakes for no industry oversight jumped in November when a leading FDA scientist, Dr. David Graham, acknowledged that Merck's drug Vioxx caused as many as 139,000 heart attacks, strokes and deaths.

Testifying before the Senate, Graham charged that Vioxx had killed between 28,000 to 55,000 people since the FDA placed it on a fast track for approval in 1999. The FDA approval came despite reports that Vioxx carried a high risk for heart attack and stroke. Internal Merck documents reveal that the company has known about the dangers of Vioxx for several years but suppressed the data and marketed it aggressively.

The FDA jumped to Merck's defense and denounced Graham as "irresponsible" and his opinions as "junk science." Previously, Graham said the agency suppressed his findings of increased risks after he reviewed 1.4 million patient records from Kaiser Permanente health care systems, showing that heart attack rates were five times higher with Vioxx, when compared to another drug.

After finding bacterial contamination at Chiron's vaccine plant in England, the FDA inspected the plant several times and then relied on telephone conference calls, letters and emails for "reinspection." In October, the British government shut down the plant for drug contamination, to the shock of the FDA.

On November 25, Graham announced that he was facing pressure from FDA officials to move out of drug safety into an administrative role, which would sidetrack him from criticizing FDA enforcement procedures. Graham warned that the FDA has abandoned its watchdog role in favor of a cozy relationship with the pharmaceutical industry and that the public can no longer expect government protection from deadly medications.

The Senate hearings came on the coattails of the influenza vaccine disaster in October, when half the nation's supply of flu vaccine was found to be contaminated. Some 48 million doses of vaccine from Chiron were taken off the market, leaving the nation far short of the 100 million doses needed for at-risk patients. With flu deaths of approximately 55,000 a year, some predict that tens of thousands will die as a result.

After finding bacterial contamination at Chiron's vaccine plant in England, the FDA inspected the plant several times and then relied on telephone conference calls, letters and emails for "reinspection." In October, the British government shut down the plant for drug contamination, to the shock of the FDA.

Public reassurances over the flu vaccine and the FDA's response to the dangers of Vioxx are in stark contrast to the recent warnings about the abortion drug RU-486. The FDA issued detailed warnings after one death, reinforcing public perception of the FDA being used for ideological purposes that have little to do with public health.

The RU-486 warnings come as a surprise from an agency that's increasingly siding with the pharmaceutical industry. OMB Watch, a nonprofit government watchdog group found, "This administration has abandoned work on scores of long-identified public health, safety, and environmental problems. The FDA and EPA alone have withdrawn 60 percent and 52 percent, respectively, of the agenda items carried over from previous administrations."

In 2004, the FDA failed to meet 70 percent of their own benchmarks for proposed rulemaking, final deadlines and reaching decisions on petitions with deadly consequences. For example, in October 2003, the FDA announced they would issue warnings about the risks and fatal side effects of a toxic heart drug, Cordarone. After 1,000 deaths and thousands of severe medical complications, the FDA has yet to act. The FDA asked the drugs manufacturer, Wyeth, to write their own regulations, which they have failed to complete.

According to OMB Watch, the FDA has withdrawn 48 identified food and drug safety priorities, almost half of all items on their agenda in May 2002. It's no wonder.

Responsible for changing the FDA is Bush appointee for legal affairs, Daniel Troy. Former clerk for Robert Bork, litigant for the anti-regulatory Washington Legal Foundation, and tobacco lawyer, Troy last represented drug maker Pfizer, collecting up to $415,000 a year in fees.

Unlike his predecessor who held one meeting with industry lobbyists, Troy has held over 129 meetings in his three years in office. But Troy's boldest move has been helping drug companies defeat lawsuits. In four separate cases since 2002, the government has asked judges to dismiss potentially costly claims against drug makers.

The lack of FDA enforcement is consistent with Bush's policy of allowing corporations to regulate themselves--akin, critics claim, to "allowing the fox to guard the henhouse." If there's a theme to Bush's oversight of public health and welfare, it's that corporate profits trump public safety and public interest.

Unfortunately, FDA regulations are not like the long-term health effects of allowing air pollution, contaminated drinking water or forest clear-cutting. FDA oversight is a life-and-death issue for the American public. A slight majority put Bush in the White House in 2004, but they evidently overlooked the dire consequences of their choice.

How many people have to die before the Bush Administration steps in with government regulators to oversee illegal and unhealthy industry practices?


Don Monkerud is an Aptos, California-based writer who follows politics.



Copyright © 2004 The Baltimore Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

This story was published on December 17, 2004.

 
Local News & Opinion

05.07 YouthWorks Campaign Needs Support for Summer Jobs

Books, Arts & Education

05.15 Frances Fox Piven's "Challenging Authority"

05.15 Major Omissions Flaw Book on Global Economics

05.14 George W. Bush’s Other Undeclared War: NCLB

05.13 New Buchanan Book: Anglo-American Ascendancy Lost in Unnecessary Wars

04.30 A Litany of Horrors

04.17 Peter Hallward's "Damming the Flood" (Part II)

Letters

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Health & Environment

05.12 The World above 350 ppm CO2

04.28 Green Scare State Terrorism

04.21 Hunger Plagues Haiti and the World

04.16 WORLD FACING HUGE NEW CHALLENGE ON FOOD FRONT

Ref. : Single-Payer FAQ

Ref. : Environmental Health News

Ref. : Sundance Channel's THE GREEN

Ref. : What is Global Warming, and what can citizens do about it?

Ref. : Global Warming Links

Ref. : Health & Nutrition Links

Media Watching

05.06 US Media Trivializes Campaign 2008

05.06 Death's Factotum: Michael Gordon and the Times Pour Pentagon Poison into Nation's Ear

05.05 TV News Blackout on Pentagon Pundits

05.05 Color-Coded: Jeremiah Wright and the Real Deal on Race

05.02 The Right's America-Hating Preacher

04.23 Pentagon Pundits

04.22 US News Media's Latest Disgrace

04.18 ABC's Debate Debacle

04.16 Reprising the Genocidal Fury of Thomas Friedman

US Politics, Policy & Culture

05.16 Danger: Tough Talk & Wishful Thinking

05.14 Bush Operative Pushes Voter-ID Law

05.13 Hillary Clinton, John McCain and the "Stupid" Vote

05.13 McCain and the 'Unitary Executive'

05.09 The Democratic Presidential Race: A View from Pennsylvania

05.08 Serving the System: Corporate Control of U.S. Would Continue Under Obama

05.06 A Republican for Barack

05.05 Thinking About Voter Registrations

05.05 'Beware the Terrible Simplifiers'

05.01 U.S. Military Coordinated Day Of Prayer Events With Christian Right Group

04.30 John McCain Won’t Be Looking for the Union Label

04.30 Put Him Out With the Pastor!

04.25 Clinton Courted Racists in the Pennsylvania Primary

04.24 Groundbreaking Book Documents Widespread Election Fraud; Warns Elections Vulnerable to Theft

04.24 Triviamongering in the U.S. presidential race

04.24 Campaign 1988 Lives!

04.23 Hillary Clinton's Monstrous Threat

04.21 Brilliant Disguise: Bush Torture, Obama and The Boss

04.19 The Clintons, Triangulating with China

04.18 American Hegemony Is Not Guaranteed

04.18 Are the Clintons Playing Joe McCarthy?

04.17 The Weather Underground 'Theme'

US “High Crimes” & Incompetence

05.16 Election Fraud, not Voter Fraud, is a National Security Threat

05.16 Constitution’s Checks, Balances Failing As Bush Prepares Iran Attack

05.14 Falling Cedars: Fomenting War in Lebanon -- and Beyond

05.12 Armed Truce: Surging Into Slaughter on Sadr City's Jerusalem Street

05.10 Lost E-Mails Obscure 'Plame-gate'

05.09 Fallujah Revisited: Bush, Petraeus Prepare 'Cleansing' of Sadr City

05.09 Shoot, Kill, Lie, Repeat: America's New Moral Universe

05.07 Willing Executioners: America's Bipartisan Atrocity Deepens in Somalia

05.05 The Terror Master: Bush Orders Covert 'Surge' Against Iran, with Dem Support

05.01 American and Israeli War Crimes: Same Atrocities, Different Responses

04.30 Halliburton Bribe Case Haunts Cheney

04.29 Getting Over Scalia

04.29 The Iraq War Morphs Into The Iranian War

04.28 The Torture Election

04.28 The Clock is Ticking for A US Attack on Iran

04.28 The Bush Team's Geneva Hypocrisy

04.25 New Terror War Atrocity: Beheading the Innocent for Bush in Somalia

04.23 Glorious Fruits of the War for Civilization

04.22 VA Tried to Conceal Extent of Attempted Veteran Suicides, Email Shows

04.21 What About the War, Benedict?

04.18 Updating Sami Al-Arian - His Ordeal Continues

04.16 Would Obama Hold Bush Accountable?

Economics & Business

05.12 Thinking About Strategies

05.08 Portrait of an Oil-Addicted Former Superpower

04.28 Thinking About Subtleties

04.23 The Oil Vice

04.22 The US Economy and the Costs of War

04.21 Thinking About Shakiness

International

05.16 Africa Must Produce or Perish

05.16 Grow Them Young, Pay Them Well - Anti-Chavistas, That Is

05.12 Disturbing Stirrings - Ratcheting Up For War on Iran

05.05 Sixty Years of Palestinian Displacement, Occupation and Suffering

05.02 Feeding Moloch: Last Barriers to War on Iran Come Down

05.01 The Iranian Chessboard

05.01 Blood Diamonds, Blood Oil and Blood Food

05.01 Denying Palestinians Free Movement in the West Bank

04.30 The Ignored Lessons on the Stupidity of War

04.24 Breaking the Silence - Israeli Soldiers Speak

04.23 What the Iraq War is about

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.
Google
This site Web
 

Public Service Ads:
Verifiable Voting in Maryland