Newspaper logo  
 
 
Local News & Opinion

Ref. : Local Newsbriefs

Travel
Films, Arts & Education
Letters

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Open Letters:

06.24 Mr. Holder, You Must Hold Torturers Accountable

Health & Environment

06.29 Thinking about Climate

06.26 False Health-Scare Ad on CNN

06.25 Louella Learns the Limits of Medicare

06.23 The Simple Answer to America’s Health Care Crisis: Medicare for All

06.23 Tell ABC: Include Single-Payer in Healthcare Debate

06.23 Serving the Medical-Industrial Complex

06.22 Thinking about Recoveries

06.20 Obama's Health Care Waterloo

06.15 Obama, Like Clinton Before Him, is Blowing the Chance for Real Health Care Reform

06.11 Two Key Health-Care Numbers

06.10 Big Breakthroughs for Single Payer Health Care

06.10 Readying Americans for Dangerous, Mandatory Vaccinations

Media Watching

06.29 WP's Connolly Back, on Health Reform

06.17 Hypocrisy and Hope: Western Coverage, Iranian Courage

06.15 Excusing Outrages of the Right

06.11 Tying Obama to Bush's Budget Mess

US Politics, Policy & Culture

06.30 Obama's Torture Hypocrisy

06.30 Court Circular: Annals of Imperial Continuity

06.29 Obama, They Want You to Fail

06.26 Who to Trust on a Truth Commission?

06.26 Tarnished Shields: The Morally Bankrupt 'Family Values' Republican Leadership

06.25 America's "Bases of Empire"

06.24 Twelve Angry White People: Jury Nullification in a Pennsylvania Coal Town

06.24 Touring Empire's Ruins

06.23 Employers are Undermining the Economic Stimulus Program

06.19 Criminalizing Dissent: Obama Pot Calls Iranian Kettle Black

06.17 Afghanistan's Operation Phoenix

06.16 Are You Ready for War with a Demonized Iran?

06.13 Where's the Anger as the Wheels Come Off Obama's and the Democrats' Recovery Program?

06.10 Waiving the Rules for Old Glory

06.10 Obama's Era of Openness Is Closed

“High Crimes?”

07.03 Reviewing Marjorie Cohn and Kathleen Gilberd's "Rules of Disengagement"

07.01 Iraq: A Bitter Strategic Failure

06.25 It's All Good, Again: 'Uptick' in the American-Made Tides of Violence in Iraq

06.22 Obama Opposes Plame-gate Release

06.21 Dexter's Legions: The "Good" Killers of the "Good" War

06.18 Extending the Tradition: Proudly Taking American Torture Into the Future

06.15 New UN Report Denounces America's Human Rights Record

06.14 Fear Rules

Economics & Business Non/Mis/Malfeasance

07.01 Michael Hudson's "Super Imperialism:" The Economic Strategy of Imperial America

06.23 Obama's Financial Reform Proposal - A Stealth Scheme for Global Monetary Control

06.10 Cyberscares About Cyberwars Equal Cybermoney

International

07.01 Pirates of the Mediterranean

06.29 Color Revolutions, Old and New

06.25 Iran Divided & the 'October Suprise'

06.23 Astringent Corrective: AbuKhalil on Iran's Turmoil

06.22 Reviewing F. William Engdahl's "Full Spectrum Dominance: Totalitarian Democracy in the New World Order:" Part I

06.20 Are the Iranian Protests Another US Orchestrated “Color Revolution?”

06.20 Through a Glass Darkly: Sifting Myth and Fact on Iran

06.19 Iran's Election and US - Iranian Elections

06.16 The Ir-Af-Pak War: Obama Looses the Manhunters

06.12 Israeli War Crimes Against Children During Operation Cast Lead

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.
Google
This site Web
  Newly Discovered Nuances to the Camp David Accords
Newspaper logo

HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE:

Newly Discovered Nuances to the Camp David Accords

by Stuart Markoff
Recently declassified documents in the Carter Library and Center in Atlanta reveal that Begin made Carter and Sadat swear never to use the phrase “Palestinian State” during their talks or in their accords.
The story remains fascinating. A new American President of uncertain aims and sympathies, deeply religious, brings together a newly elected Israeli premier of equally uncertain motives with the Egyptian President who had surprised the world by flying to Jerusalem.

President Carter finds himself obliged to perform “shuttle diplomacy” between principals who refuse to talk directly with each other at Camp David. By dint of sheer persistence, he brings Menachem Begin and Anwar Sadat to an agreement in October 1978 that a few months later will produce the first peace treaty between Israel and one of its most implacable foes.

Somehow that treaty has remained valid, if not exactly productive of increased good will or trade relations. The concession of giving up the Sinai, won in the 1967 Six Days War, has guaranteed Egypt’s never again waging open war, as it had recently done in the surprise Yom Kippur attack. That near-disaster brought down Golda Meir’s government and brought the rightest Likud party to power for the first time since the founding of Israel.

American Jews were very nervous about Jimmy Carter and even more nervous about Begin. Both were unknown quantities. Yet it took a man from the right (as it did in America’s recognition of China), with a push from Ariel Sharon of all people, to make the deal with Egypt. Israel would no longer have to worry about an attack coming from the Southwest.

On her recent visit to Beth Tfiloh’s Sagner Auditorium, former Secretary of State Madeleine Albright reacted with surprise when she learned that Begin had made a condition on his coming to Camp David. Recently declassified documents in the Carter Library and Center in Atlanta reveal that Begin had made President Carter and President Sadat swear never to use the phrase “Palestinian State” or any reference thereto during their talks or in their accords.

Nonetheless, Begin was to come under severe personal criticism by suggesting his agreement to eventual “Palestinian autonomy” —to some, giving away the store, as it were. Carter felt betrayed on what he had taken for promises by Begin to give up the “settlements,” or disputed territories.

In my review of Carter’s briefing papers during the Camp David period, as well as memos from that time to and from his National Security Advisor Zbigniew Brezizinsky, we can trace the President’s learning curve and see how quick a study he was. After all, in the sheer bluebook sense, Carter was one of the most intelligent of our presidents, personally trained in nuclear submarines by Admiral Rickover.

If he seemed a stranger to American Jewry, American Jewry knew even less about him. The doubts about his commitment to Israel have continued to the present day, inflamed by the use of the term “apartheid” in the title of his latest book, which by the way Mrs. Albright labeled as “abominable"—with some courage while standing before a very pro-Carter crowd in February at the Carter Center, the ex-President himself standing next to her.

So what did Carter know that fall of 1978? He knew that Jews were less than 3 percent of America’s population but had a disproportionately high representation in the House of Representatives and in the Senate. His Chief of Staff provided a list of each member.

He knew that AIPAC had been formed back in 1958 to answer then-Secretary of State John Foster Dulles’s exasperated query, “Which Jews?” to talk to among the many organizations that claimed to speak for American Jewry. By 1978, AIPAC had few serious challengers to its dominant position.

Carter knew that Jewish money had gone almost as heavily into backing his defeated Republican rival as had gone into Democratic coffers. In fact, far more money had gone into Nixon’s 1974 campaign than into McGovern’s. He had a refresher course on the whole sweep of Jewish history and the creation of Israel out of the ashes of the Holocaust.

And he was aware, and skeptical, of the State Department’s long antipathy to Israel as of no strategic interest to the U.S. Of course, he also knew that Nixon’s Secretary of State, Kissinger, had rescued Israel with resupplies and airlifts during the Yom Kippur War.

Since then, the two countries had become almost interdependent, with America serving as the supplier of arms and billions in annual grants from Congress. Yet there was a delicate balancing act with other Middle Eastern states, with arms and money also going to Egypt, Saudi Arabia and Jordan.

And of course we now know how Carter’s support collapsed. Thanks in large part to back-channel manipulations by supporters of the Reagan candidacy, Carter himself was held hostage to the hostage crisis in Iran after the Shah had been overthrown. He lost his bid for re-election despite nearly bringing off real peace in the Middle East. He could at least console himself with a Nobel Peace Prize.

Most Jews still find themselves uncomfortable with the man from Plains, Georgia.
Although he has corrected a few matters of fact in his controversial book, Jimmy Carter will not back down on calling Israel’s policies to its Arab citizens as amounting to “apartheid.” Whether this is just a stubborn streak or a deeply-held belief and observation (and condemnation, justified or not), most Jews still find themselves uncomfortable with the man from Plains, Georgia.

Nonetheless, few would disagree with the assertion that he has been our greatest ex-President since John Quincy Adams, even after apologizing for his breach of decorum in referring to the current Administration as “the worst in our history.”


Stuart Markoff studied nuclear weapons policy under Henry Kissinger at Harvard. He is continuing his researches in the Jimmy Carter Presidential Library/Ctr. in Atlanta, Georgia.


Copyright © 2007 The Baltimore Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

This story was published on June 19, 2007.
 

Public Service Ads:
Verifiable Voting in Maryland