| ||||||||||||||
|
Local News & Opinion
09.25 State Elections Boards Seeks Volunteers to Help Process Unprecedented Number of Voter Applications Travel
Books, Arts & Education
09.18 Reviewing Danny Schechter's "Plunder: Investigating Our Economic Calamity and the Subprime Scandal" Letters
Ref. : Letters to the editor Open Letters:
09.30 To Joe Biden: Time for Confession 09.28 Open Letter to Senator Barack Obama 09.26 Bailout Package Must be Transparent to the American People 09.18 Possible $2 Million Donation to Support Md. Slots Sends Wrong Message Health & Environment
Media Watching
10.11 Censored News Stories in US Highlighted by Academic Research Group 10.11 Without a Trace: The Smokeless Gun of Flagrant Election Fixing 10.10 Ayers = Keating? 10.02 Project Censored's Media Democracy Advocacy 09.23 Satire: Louella Reads the Baltimore Sun 09.22 CBS Cheats on Tax Coverage 09.10 Post's Post-Convention 'Balancing' Act 09.10 McCain/Palin Campaign Relies on Lazy Thinking and Prejudice to Win 09.10 The Rising Cost of the Iraq 'Surge' US Politics, Policy & Culture
10.09 McCain-Palin Put 'Country Last' 10.07 GOP Judges Aid White House Cover-up 10.07 Voting the Fate of the Nation 10.07 Alaska GOP's Last-Ditch Palin Defense 10.07 Election '08: Here Comes the Sludge 10.02 John McCain v. The Truth 10.02 Drinking at the Public Fountain 10.01 Who won the Mississippi debate? Obama—but for different reasons than you think 09.30 The Shadow of the Pitchfork: Elite Panic Attack as Bailout Goes Bust 09.29 The Resurrectionists: Beltway's Big Money Cultists Bail Out the Dead 09.29 We Have the Money 09.27 Debate Evades Dark Realities 09.26 Alaskan Officials Allege Palin Cover-up 09.24 Don’t Worry, Be Happy 09.24 Text of Draft Proposal for Bailout Plan 09.24 Hey, Government! How About Calling on Us? 09.23 Coming Attractions: War Without End, Amen 09.22 The Evolution of John McCain 09.21 Palin's 'Troopergate' Battle Rages 09.19 Burning the First Amendment 09.15 Subverting Democracy Through Electoral Fraud 09.15 Military Industrial Complex 2.0 09.13 Acceptable Sacrifice: For the Right to Endorse 09.13 Why More Soldiers from Alaska? 09.12 Experience is Over-Rated 09.10 Obama Must Call for Palin's Removal from the Ticket 09.10 9/11 Plus Seven 09.10 Palin's Strange Probe of a Trooper 09.10 Dear Democrats: Integrity Won’t Win this Election US High Crimes
10.09 The Surge That Failed 10.08 The Orwellosphere: Anglo-American Drive to 'Total Security State' Rolls On 10.08 Justice for Yemini Sheik 10.06 The Wounded Shark: 'Good War' Lost, But the Imperial Project Goes On 10.02 U.S. Army Troops To Serve As U.S. Policemen? 09.25 Life on the Ledge 09.16 "Awakening" Into Nightmare: Seeding More Sectarian War in Iraq Economics & Business
10.06 Thinking About Treason 10.06 The Fleecing of America 10.03 Can a bailout succeed? 10.02 Empire of Greed 10.02 No Surprise in the Senate Bailout Vote 10.02 How Wall Street Can Bail Itself Out Without Destroying The Dollar 10.02 The Specter of Wall Street 10.01 We Need to Demand Hearings! 09.30 Surprise! Congress Listened to the Voting Public! 09.29 Thinking About Gyrations 09.29 Grand Theft America 09.26 Seizing America by Withholding the Mother’s Milk of Politics 09.26 Framing the $700 Billion Question 09.26 Bail Out NO, Buy Out YES 09.26 Just Say "No" to Any Immediate Bailout 09.26 Has Deregulation Sired Fascism? 09.25 Don't Fuel the Fire: Fire the Arsonists 09.25 America Pays the Piper, Big Time 09.24 Just Thinking Aloud Here 09.23 What Nobody's Saying: The Bailout Will Kill the Dollar 09.22 Thinking About Escalations 09.18 US Economy: Rudderless and Reeling From Direct Hits 09.18 US Economy: Rudderless and Reeling From Direct Hits 09.17 Creative Destruction: The Solid Core Behind the Financial Crisis 09.16 You Can't Feel Blue About the Economy If You Want To. There Are No Blue Chips Anymore 09.15 Thinking About Spotlights 09.15 U.S. Economy—Temporary Respite, Permanent Decline International
10.10 Another Israeli West Bank Land Grab Scheme 09.26 Annals of Liberation: Sex is Death in a Darkened Land 09.25 New Coup D'Etat Rumblings in Venezuela 09.22 Remembering Edward Said Five Years On 09.20 Filter Tips: Distortion and Demonization on the Iran Beat 09.11 Wall Street and Washington We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.
|
BOOK REVIEW & COMMENTARYJeff Halper's An Israeli in Palestine (Part II)Ultimately, Israel will fail in its attempt "to transform its Matrix of Control (and permanent Occupation) into a stable, peaceful state of affairs."
According to Israeli-based author and journalist Jonathan Cook, Halper's book is "one of the most insightful analyses of the Occupation I've read. His voice cries out to be heard" on the region's longest and most intractable conflict. (Begin with Part I.) Part II continues the story. Part III: The Structure of Oppression - Expanding Dispossession, The Occupation and the Matrix of Control
What 1948 left undone, 1967 completed - securing control over the entire "Holy Land" with the seizure of Gaza, the West Bank and all of Jerusalem. Nishul's fifth stage began and today includes expanding West Bank settlements and continued displacement inside Israel. After the Six-Day War, all Palestinians came under military rule, and "a comprehensive Matrix of Control was implemented to perpetuate Israeli control forever." A problem arose, however, as international law prohibits an occupier from remaining permanently. Israel's Attorney General, Meir Shamgar, got around it in typical Israeli fashion. No "occupation" exists so Israel didn't violate Geneva or other international law. In other words, "occupation" only occurs when one sovereign state conquers another, so presto - Palestine wasn't sovereign and Israel did nothing illegal. This has no legitimacy in international law, yet Israel gets away with it, and it's the reason it calls the West Bank (and formerly Gaza) "disputed," not "occupied." Furthermore, Shamgar's ruling affected Supreme Court decisions ever since and lets Israel expand its settlement project on annexed Palestinian land. Immediately after the 1967 war, the Labor government began "integrating Judea, Samaria and Gaza to Israel." After Menachem Begin's 1977 election, he appointed Ariel Sharon to head a Ministerial Committee on Settlements and gave him the job to do it. He was charged with two tasks:
It has four modes of control:
Concluding Dispossession: Oslo and Unilateral Separation
Oslo represented nishul's sixth stage, "a kind of occupation-by-consent," according to Halper. It's explained above with a few more comments to add. Israel's "security" is key to any peace process. So is getting Palestinian acquiescence to all Israeli demands and being willing to act as its enforcer. The process was flawed by design, collapsed under its own weight, led to the second Intifada, and awakened peace activists to be more proactive for their cause. It also inspired Halper to establish ICAHD, and he's been active in it since. Oslo's failure got Israelis to "hunker down" and make "security" their foremost issue. It also explains their willingness to elect Ariel Sharon Prime Minister. Halper says "Everything he did had a clear focus and purpose: beating the Palestinians into submission, extending Israel's sovereignty to the Jordan River and preventing the establishment of a viable Palestinian state." He would complete the final nishul stage, and by luck he took power along with George Bush, his close friend and willing co-conspirator. They had a common agenda and 9/11 advanced it - in four decisive stages:
Part IV: Overcoming Oppression - Redeeming Israel
Here's where things now stand. "Israel/Palestine (is) at a crossroads." Israel's political leadership believes it's won. The settlement project is in place. It "ensures permanent control over the entire Land of Israel." Palestine is cantonized. The "facts on the ground" are established. America is on board. So are Europeans. The Arab world is indifferent. A mere political act will make Occupation permanent. Israel offers no concessions, Palestinians have no say, and as of now have no chance for a fair and equitable solution - or so Israel thinks. Is it so? Halper's view is this, and many share it: Ultimately, Israel will fail in its attempt "to transform its Matrix of Control (and permanent Occupation) into a stable, peaceful state of affairs." Oppressed people everywhere "have one source of leverage: the power to say 'no.' " And Palestinians have said it for six decades. For six more if they have to. For as long as it takes to get the justice they deserve. For all their wishes? Maybe not, but enough to matter and be able to end the most intractable conflict anywhere. Be assured - it will happen, one way or other, at some future time. Hamas is a powerful symbol - of the future - the power to say "no," or as Halper puts it: "To hell with"......Israel, its Matrix of Control, America, the international community, the dismissive Arab world, and corrupted Fatah. We won't submit; won't play your rigged game; won't let you crush us; won't let you deny us our rights; in the end you'll come to us, and we'll prevail. If six decades of struggle doesn't prove it, what then will. We'll give you six more, and more still. Had enough? Now we'll set the terms. Think it can't happen? Read on. One day Israel and the world community will reach an inevitable conclusion. The price of Occupation is too great - regional instability, global also, continued war, maybe nuclear, and a potential cost far too great to risk. Push will come to shove when it's too great to chance. Palestinians like Jews and people everywhere have national rights of self-determination provided they don't impinge on others with equal rights. Ethnocracies like Israel don't work. Nor do they in the Muslim or Christian worlds. And understand the distinction. France for the French and Mexico for Mexicans aren't the same as Israel for the Jews. France like most countries have Christians, Jews, Muslims, whatever - all entitled to equal rights under law. Israel only affords them only to Jews - an untenable system doomed to fail. When it's realized, push will have come to shove, and then some. So where are we, and what's ahead? Halper doesn't have a solution, but he offers an approach based on "indispensable" elements:
Only a rights-based win-win solution can work; one under international law; apartheid is untenable; human rights reframing advances the de-colonization argument; why elsewhere but not in Israel. Sum it up and here are Halper's choices:
What About Terrorism? First off, distinguish between individual/group v. the far greater state kind. Then consider aggressors and victims, one act begetting another, an eventual vicious circle, and nations claiming the high ground when they're at fault - "worthy" victims of "unworthy" ones even when they act in self-defense. The real issues is life. It's sacred, and taking it from non-combatants is terrorism. It's also "illegal, immoral and prohibited." Self-defense against combatants is another matter fully justified under international law as is the right to resist with arms. Israel says otherwise, blames its victims, and so far has avoided accountability. That no longer can stand, and Halper suggests a "better language" to hold all terrorist acts accountable. It exists so let's use it - the language of human rights. It's codified in law, and it's high time it's applied universally. It's precise, inclusive and condemns all forms of terror - by individuals, groups and most importantly states. And judicial bodies exist to enforce it - the International Criminal Court (ICC) for example to prosecute individuals for genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes, and crimes of aggression. The principle of "universal jurisdiction" also exists that requires other states to bring rights violators (including heads of state) to trial if their own nation won't do it. Halper sees human rights and applying international law as key to genuine peace and conflict resolution. States, of course, are the obstacle. They won't police themselves, and in-place institutions have proved weak. Changing things requires people action - international civil society demanding justice; doing it proactively; marshaling enough voices to make them heard; refusing to take no for an answer. Think impossible? Think again. Where Do We Go From Here? Here's the problem. The Israeli-Palestinian conflict involves far more than two peoples. Far more than the region. It's global and resonates everywhere and affects everyone. For the Middle East alone, regional peace is impossible without a just settlement of the conflict. Absent that and anything is possible - all bad. Globally, the entire world is affected. For Halper, it's brought him "full circle," a Jew, an Israeli in Palestine seeing his "own people coopted by Israel's security framing and disempowered." Disadvantaged as well considering the alternative. He's part of an effort to change things and suggests four strategic elements: (1) A global, regional, local and personal vision The last two decades have seen the emergence of a vibrant international civil society - thousands of peace and human rights organizations of all types together with activists, intellectuals and concerned people everywhere standing up against injustice and demanding resolution. So far, the other side outmuscles them, but who knows for how long. New tools are around like the Internet that connects people everywhere. Alternative media as well, including online choices attracting growing audiences fed up with the mainstream's mind-numbing array. That combination against injustice has power. Omnipotent - no. Effective - why not, and in enough numbers it works. Social movements comprised of ordinary people have enormous political clout. They can win when they're of a mind to, but it's no simple task. It takes muscle-flexing, exercising "disruptive power," according to Frances Fox Piven, and look what it brought America - ending slavery, labor and civil rights and a liberating revolution from Britain. Why not one freeing Palestinians from Occupation. But it needs an effective program for action. Here's Halper's:
Redeeming Israel fits in as well. Making it an "exclusive patrimony" created a "violent nightmare....a self-defeating enterprise." The more Jews "try to Judaize Palestine, the more (they) destroy it" and themselves. The situation is untenable and begs for an alternative. Political Zionism is "exhausted." A prosperous and formidable Jewish state has failed - to achieve "accommodation, justice, peace and reconciliation" with Palestinians, the region, and international civil society. A "New Cultural Zionism" is needed, disassociating itself from self-defeating politics and its corrupting violence. What's good for Jews is good for Arabs is good for everyone. Halper "can't argue with that." Can anyone? His book is powerful, enlightening, and important to read and act on. Stephen Lendman lives in Chicago and can be reached at
lendmanstephen@sbcglobal.net. Also visit his blog site at sjlendman.blogspot.com, and
listen to The Global Research News Hour
on RepublicBroadcasting.org Mondays from 11AM—1PM US
Central time.Mr. Lendman's stories are republished in the Baltimore Chronicle with permission of the author. Copyright © 2008 The Baltimore News Network. All rights reserved.
Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent. Baltimore News Network, Inc., sponsor of this web site, is a nonprofit organization and does not make political endorsements. The opinions expressed in stories posted on this web site are the authors' own. This story was published on July 25, 2008. |
| ||||||||||||