Newspaper logo  
 
 
Local News & Opinion
Travel
Books, Arts & Education

08.05 "American Teen": A Winning Documentary about Real-Life High Schoolers

07.31 Francis Boyle's "Palestine Palestinians and International Law"

Letters

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Open Letters:

08.16 Out Damn Blot: A Letter to Colin Powell

Health & Environment

08.14 The End of Cheap Oil: The Future is Now

08.05 Obama is Right: It's Easy to Reduce the Nation's (and Your Own) Fuel Bill Dramatically

Media Watching

08.21 Mixed Truth of the Russia-Georgia War

08.16 John McCain's Party of Hate

08.15 Corporate Media Bashes New Chavez Enabling Law Decrees

08.15 Georgia/Russia Conflict Forced Into Cold War Frame

08.13 WPost and the Great Disconnect

08.12 WPost Admits Bungling Obama Quote

08.06 Why McCain May Well Win

08.06 Media Fall for 'Race Card' Spin

08.01 Wall Street Journalomics: The Case of the Missing Tax Facts

07.31 CNN Scoffs at White House Critics

07.31 WPost Calls Out 'Uppity' Obama

US Politics, Policy & Culture

08.21 McCain's Ties to Neocon Hard Lines

08.21 Peace Mom v. Guardian of Power

08.20 Are You Ready For Nuclear War?

08.19 A Book Written to Defeat Obama

08.19 McCain's 'Cone of Silence' Caper

08.14 Is Perpetual War Our Future?

08.12 5 Years After Blackout, Power Grid Still in 'Dire Straits'

08.12 Olympic Shame

08.12 Thinking About Intermissions

08.11 ‘Medaling’ With Free Speech at the Olympics

08.11 Targeting Immigrants - The Largest Ever US ICE Raid

08.09 A Novel Approach to Politics

08.07 The Hamdan Principle and You

08.07 McCain Adopts Cheney's Energy Plan

08.06 The Serpent's Egg: Solzhenitsyn and the Origins of America's Gulag

08.05 Mining Racism and Murder in a Northeastern Pennsylvania Coal Town

08.04 The Other Presidential Candidates

08.03 McCain, Anthrax & the Afghan Blunder

08.01 Justice Probe Still Threatens Gonzales

07.31 Obama's Surge in Berlin

07.30 War Without End, Amen: Into the Afghan Abyss with Obama

07.30 McCain's Spin on the 'Surge'

07.30 Friday's House Judiciary Hearing on Impeachment: A Victory and a Challenge

US “High Crimes” & Misdemeanors

08.20 Musharraf, Not Bush, Follows Nixon

08.18 Fear, Procurement, Profit: Permanent War and the American Way

08.17 This Time, the World Is Not Buying It

08.15 'Imminent' Threats Should Be a Belli Laugh

08.08 American Insouciance

08.07 Extra! Dog Bites Man! Read All About It!

08.05 Marching Off Into Tyranny

08.05 Follow This Dime

07.31 Wave of 'Capitol Crime' Continues

07.29 Bodyguard of Lies: The Truth Behind the 'Surge's' Smokescreen

07.28 Secret "Torture Memo" Gave Legal Cover to Interrogators Who Acted in "Good Faith"

07.28 The Bush Administration's Secret Biowarfare Agenda

07.26 The Endless Smearing of Joe Wilson

Economics & Business

08.04 Thinking About Ponzi

International

08.18 Blockades: Acts of War

08.17 Rice’s Recipe for Duck Soup

08.14 The Lawless Roads: Bluster in Georgia, Rank Tyranny at Home

08.14 Marching Through Georgia V: U.S. Forces Moving Into Putin's Powderkeg

08.14 Marching Through Georgia IV: The Butt Thumper and the Bear

08.13 Using Georgia to Target Russia

08.12 From Stupid to Moronic to Evil

08.11 Marching Through Georgia III: Reality's Rout and Cheney's Viagra

08.11 Marching Through Georgia II: The Kremlin Surge

08.08 Marching Through Georgia I: Cold War II Proxy Conflict Turns Hot

08.07 Living Death: The Eternal Now of Hiroshima

08.07 War with Iran - On, Off or Undecided?

08.04 Gaza Under Siege

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.
Google
This site Web
 
  Thinking About Ponzi
Newspaper logo

ECONOMIC ANALYSIS:

Thinking About Ponzi

by Fred Cederholm

Ponzi’s flash-in-the-pan pyramid scheme pales in comparison to the complexity and sums of money involved in the financial shenanigans that are unwinding/ unraveling before our eyes some 80 years later.

I’ve been thinking about Ponzi. Actually I’ve been thinking about schemes/pyramids, the press, governmental investigations, the past, and our present dilemmas. As the summer of 2008 progresses, there is a growing undercurrent of concern gnawing at the very foundations of our financial/economic systems. Page one news stories talk of losses and write-offs in the mega BILLIONS. The investors of the planet played fast and loose with money they had (or money they leveraged). Their judgment was clouded by visions of easy money and big returns. Now they see mountains of losses, not profits. They are wary of being bitten or taken twice. Such hard-learned caution will prove a major obstacle to any long-term recovery or any quick turnaround.

You see, Charles (Carlo) Ponzi (1882-1949) is forever identified with the pyramiding scam which bears his name. Ponzi was a wheeler-dealer from the moment he got off the boat from Italy in 1903. He soon relocated to Canada, where he worked as a teller at a bank that was growing by leaps and bounds because it paid more money in interest than its competition. He saw that the “premium” being paid was financed by new deposits, not from operational profits. The game worked only as long as a steady stream of new money and customers underwrote any would-be withdrawals of the earlier deposits. Rollovers and continued cash infusions were essential. The bank eventually failed, and Ponzi’s boss fled Canada with the remaining funds. Ponzi was apprehended and ended up doing time for an unrelated check fraud rap. Still... he had learned much from his former employer!

After his release, Ponzi relocated to the US, where he was soon arrested for smuggling in illegal immigrants, and he served two more years. Upon his release, he settled in Boston, where he came up with a money-raising scheme involving international postage reply coupons—effectively selling “prepaid return postage stamps.” He promised a 50% return on a 45-day investment, paying lucrative commissions to his sales force for every friend and family member they enticed into investing. He started his own company, the Securities Exchange Company (the SEC!) to promote the scheme. (Has a nice “ring” to it, don’t you think?)

His take in Feb. 1920 was $5,000, by March it was $ 30,000, by May it was $420,000—and by July his take was in the MILLIONS; by then he was raking in $250,000 a day!

An alert local press and government began to question (and investigate) his money-making model. On Aug. 10, the Feds shut down Ponzi’s “SEC,” and on Aug. 13 he was arrested and charged with 86 counts of fraud. He pled guilty to mail fraud on Nov. 1 and was sentenced to five years in prison. He served three and a half years, only to be sentenced to nine more years on state charges. He was ultimately deported in 1934.

Ponzi’s flash-in-the-pan pyramid scheme pales in comparison to the complexity and sums of money involved in the financial shenanigans that are unwinding/unraveling before our eyes some 80 years later. His mess was local to New England. Our messes are nationwide and global. Still... there are similarities—and differences—to the Hell Ponzi had wrought, and the looming crises “we” face.

To present and future would-be investors, loss of large returns today is not as devastating as the fear of losing principal.

In substance over form, both scenarios necessitate an ongoing and increasing influx of new money and investor/lenders to keep the “engines” chugging away. This is far more critical than the greed-driven quest for easy money and a fast buck. To present and future would-be investors, loss of large returns today is not as devastating as the fear of losing principal (or investment basis).

How is the housing crisis to be solved without new buyers armed with fresh borrowings? How can GDP consumption continue (much less grow) based solely on earned incomes? How will retirees draw on promised retirement benefits without the ongoing influx of future workers’ tax withholdings? How will retired autoworkers draw their pensions without profits from future car sales? How will Uncle $ugar re-finance any weekly redemptions and additional borrowings from our national debt without the continued/expanded largesse of foreign creditors? Ditto for our ballooning trade deficits.

Ponzi’s victims had to eat their losses, but at least he did time for his crimes. Has anyone this time around really been indicted yet?

I’m Fred Cederholm and I’ve been thinking. You should be thinking, too.


Copyright 2008 Questions, Inc. All rights reserved. Fred Cederholm is a CPA/CFE, a forensic accountant, and writer. He is a graduate of the University of Illinois (B.A., M.A. and M.A.S.). He can be reached at asklet@rochelle.net.

Copyright © 2008 The Baltimore News Network. All rights reserved.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

Baltimore News Network, Inc., sponsor of this web site, is a nonprofit organization and does not make political endorsements. The opinions expressed in stories posted on this web site are the authors' own.

This story was published on August 4, 2008.

 

Public Service Ads:
Verifiable Voting in Maryland