Newspaper logo  
Local Stories, Events

Ref. : Civic Events

Ref. : Arts & Education Events

Ref. : Public Service Notices

Books, Films, Arts & Education

09.12 Why Is College in America So Expensive?


Ref. : Letters to the editor

Health Care & Environment

09.18 'I was horrified that children are breathing air this dirty inside the school' [if your government isn't working, change it!]

09.16 Universal healthcare was unthinkable in America, but not any more

09.16 Air pollution particles found in mothers' placentas

09.16 Portugal’s radical drugs policy is working. Why hasn’t the world copied it?

09.13 The Guardian view on electric cars: stopped by industry inaction [Vroom Vroom is Dumb Dumb]

09.13 Electric future? Global push to move away from gas-powered cars

09.12 The Secret Drug Pricing System Middlemen Use to Rake in Millions

09.12 Jerry Brown: Trump's 'gross ignorance' main obstacle in climate change fight

09.12 Medicare for All and the Myth of the 40% Physician Pay Cut

09.11 Global hunger levels rising due to extreme weather, UN warns

09.11 Fossil fuel dependence poses 'direct existential threat', warns UN chief

09.11 Air pollution is 'biggest environmental health risk' in Europe [Switch to 100% renewables and stop all mining, pumping, refining and burning of fossil fuels!!!]

News Media Matters

09.14 Bob Woodward: 'Too many people are emotionally unhinged about Trump'

Daily: FAIR Blog
The Daily Howler

US Politics, Policy & 'Culture'

09.18 Voters Are Ready for a Green New Deal. Are Democrats?

09.18 'This Election Is Last Chance to Stop Them': Kudlow Confirms Trump and GOP Ready to Gut Safety Net After Midterms [Yes, there are far too many sociopaths]

09.18 You'll miss Trump one day

09.17 California plans to show the world how to meet the Paris climate target

09.17 For Whom the Climate Bell Tolls

09.16 2020 Dems: Rebels v. restorationists

09.16 Trump's Insults Against His 'Hillbilly' Base Are Making Them Turn on Him: NYT Column

09.15 Nazis May Be Bad, But Tax Cuts Are Awesome!

Justice Matters
High Crimes?

09.16 Merchants of Death Profit from the Bombing of Children as a US-Backed War Goes Largely Ignored

Economics, Crony Capitalism

09.16 If Jeff Bezos wants to help low-income people why not just pay them better?

09.16 Central Banks Have Gone Rogue, Putting Us All at Risk

International & Futurism

09.18 'Unconscionable' and 'Appalling': In Affront to Those Fleeing US-Backed Wars and Persecution, Trump Slams Door on Refugees

09.17 How to Humanely Solve Europe's Migration Crisis

09.15 A Warning From Europe: The Worst Is Yet to Come [SCARY]

09.15 Crossing Germany's divide — encounters with far-right protesters

09.14 A new authoritarian axis demands an international progressive front

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.

You can also mail a check to:
Baltimore News Network, Inc.
P.O. Box 42581
Baltimore, MD 21284-2581
This site Web
  Print view: Taxes: Messing With Mankiw

Taxes: Messing With Mankiw

by Gerald E. Scorse
Monday, 25 October 2010
Mankiw suggests his affluent ilk might just stop working if the tax breaks don't keep coming.

N. Gregory Mankiw, who chaired the Council of Economic Advisers from 2003-2005, now teaches at Harvard and writes a column for the New York Times. His recent piece, “I Can Afford Higher Taxes. But They’ll Make Me Work Less,” evoked Ayn Rand and provoked liberals. As one of the provoked, I’m here to mess with Mankiw.

Several shots have already been taken, including a charge by political blogger Kevin Drum that Mankiw fudged some figures. He did, but that’s not what bothered me.

Whining. Omissions, serious and curious. Threatening. Let’s look at those.

“I Can Afford Higher Taxes” whines about taxes Mankiw has yet to pay and, in the major case, won’t ever pay. It whines about a 2013 bump in the Medicare tax. About a 2011 deduction phaseout that will add “1.2 percentage points to my effective marginal rate.” It whines that the estate tax, lying in wait, will sabotage a father’s efforts “to put some money aside for my three children.”

Whining doesn’t become a Harvard professor who tells us, admirably, “I could go so far as to say I am almost completely sated.” Sated, but whining away.

Mankiw’s numbers on the estate tax omit a number which would likely shield any legacy he manages to scrape together: an exclusion of $3.5 million per person, or $7 million per couple. Congress has to agree on an amount, but there’s almost no way it will be less. So, unless Mankiw is even more affluent than he admits, none of the Mankiws will ever pay a dime in federal “death taxes." (Drum also caught this omission.)

Taxing Wall Street income at a lower rate than wages is the major reason why effective tax rates on the super-rich are often super-low.

With his focus on marginal rates, Mankiw also avoids the rate that really matters, the effective tax rate. The billionaire Warren Buffett aimed the spotlight where it belongs when he confessed, shame-facedly, to paying “far, far less as a fraction of my income than the secretaries or the clerks of anyone else in my office.” Might the same be true of Mankiw and the secretaries at Harvard? You’ll never get that from him; he’s called the 2003 tax cuts on capital gains and corporate dividends “an important accomplishment.” For sure: taxing Wall Street income at a lower rate than wages is the major reason why effective tax rates on the super-rich are often super-low.

“I Can Afford Higher Taxes” plainly intends to threaten us. The well-off, Mankiw infers, will withhold their services once they reach the point where the top marginal rate kicks in (and they’ve exhausted all their tax breaks, about which more later). Listen to the menace in Mankiw’s summation: “...[S]omeday, you may need treatment from a highly trained surgeon, or your child may need braces from the local orthodontist.” And the local orthodontist and the highly trained surgeon will show you the door, or never open it. Don’t say you weren’t warned.

Now for a fast lesson on tax breaks.

Mankiw’s personal blog noted that “I Can Afford Higher Taxes” struck a nerve. Here’s his response to one frequent question:

QUESTION: "Aren’t there ways to avoid some of these taxes, such as IRAs and life insurance trusts?"

MANKIW'S RESPONSE: "Yes, and I use such tax avoidance mechanisms to the extent they are legal and practical. But there are limits to how much they can be used. Thus, while they lower my average tax rate, they do not affect my marginal tax rate. That is, for any incremental income, I cannot do more, so I am facing the full tax bite.”

Here’s a man who sidles up to the tax break buffet, takes what appeals, and would gladly shovel down more if he weren’t legally stuffed.

We might keep Mankiw from whining by creating more tax breaks. Or he might hire a more creative tax accountant, and fudge numbers in some place other than The New York Times.

Gerald E. Scorse, who writes from New York City helped pass a bill that tightens the rules for reporting capital gains. Mr. Scorse's stories are republished in the Baltimore Chronicle with permission of the author.

Copyright © 2010 The Baltimore News Network. All rights reserved.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

Baltimore News Network, Inc., sponsor of this web site, is a nonprofit organization and does not make political endorsements. The opinions expressed in stories posted on this web site are the authors' own.

This story was published on October 25, 2010.

Public Service Ads: