Newspaper logo  
 
 
Local News & Opinion

Ref. : Civic Events

Ref. : Arts & Education Events

Ref. : Public Service Notices

Travel
Books, Films, Arts & Education
Letters
Open Letters:

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Health Care & Environment

07.03 George Lakoff: Why Pope Francis Killed It on Addressing Climate Change

07.03 This dome in the Pacific houses tons of radioactive waste – and it's leaking

07.03 Jairam Ramesh: India can't remain on the path of further destruction

07.03 Greenpeace and utilities launch suit against Hinkley nuclear plant

07.03 New study warns of dangerous climate change risks to the Earth’s oceans [ginormous graphic]

07.03 BP set to pay largest environmental fine in US history for Gulf oil spill

07.02 Australia must cut carbon emissions by 30% by 2025, says Climate Change Authority

07.02 Germany to mothball largest coal power plants to meet climate targets

07.02 Supreme Court Decision Unlikely to Stall the Shift Away from Coal Plants

07.02 Hope for Alzheimer's treatment as researchers find licensed drugs halt brain degeneration

07.02 The Death Treatment

07.01 Rich countries' $100bn promise to fight climate change 'not delivered'

07.01 Climate change a security risk second only to terrorism, says defence report

07.01 China makes carbon pledge ahead of Paris climate change summit

07.01 Brazil announces massive reforestation and renewable energy plan with US

07.01 Are we on the brink of an electric car revolution?

07.01 Billions have no access to toilets, says World Health Organisation report

News Media

07.02 This despicable “O’Reilly Factor” segment exposes the fundamental ugliness of the right-wing worldview [5:24 video]

07.01 How Chris Christie trapped himself in a political quandary [A paper-of-record spreads an old Social Security lie]

Daily FAIR Blog
The Daily Howler

US Politics, Policy & 'Culture'

07.03 Elizabeth Warren Reams Private Accreditor Who Certified Corinthian College Up to Its End [6:17 video]

07.03 Economic exodus means two-thirds of Puerto Ricans may soon live in US

07.02 America’s worst governors want to be president: Jindal, Walker, Christie — can Sam Brownback be far behind

07.02 Bernie Sanders draws crowd of 10,000 at Wisconsin rally[2:59 video]

07.01 How Chris Christie trapped himself in a political quandary [A paper-of-record spreads an old Social Security lie]

07.01 KKK plans South Carolina rally as Confederate flag debate continues

07.01 How Seattle Is Reclaiming Its Waterfront From an Elevated Urban Highway

07.01 Affordable Housing Crisis Grows Across the Country as Apartment Rents Skyrocket

06.30 Wealth Doesn't Trickle Down, But the Effects of Housing Discrimination Do

06.30 What's Really Happening in Puerto Rico? [As with Greece, expect mass population shift to avoid local government debt-service taxes]

06.30 The GOP Fails Its Empathy Test

06.30 Barack Obama moves to double US salary limit on overtime pay

06.29 Bernie Sanders can give America what it needs: Some good old-fashioned class warfare

06.29 Puerto Rico’s Governor Says Island’s Debts Are ‘Not Payable’

Justice Matters
High Crimes?
Economics, Crony Capitalism

07.03 Europe’s Many Economic Disasters

07.01 How the euro became a weapon of mass destruction

06.30 Robert Reich: America is facing an economic apartheid

06.30 Europe’s Attack on Greek Democracy

06.29 The economic plan that could save America (but scares conservative billionaires senseless)

06.29 Report: Millions of dollars in fraud, waste found in charter school sector [a BIG overlooked story of the failure to sensibly regulate]

06.29 The world is defenceless against the next financial crisis, warns BIS

International

07.03 Boko Haram attack on Nigerian village leaves nearly 100 people dead

07.02 Nicholas Winton, Rescuer of 669 Children From Holocaust, Dies at 106

07.02 Weak Power Grids in Africa Stunt Economies and Fire Up Tempers

07.02 Greece's economic crisis: 100 Greeks give their view

07.02 Hillary Clinton emails reveal powerful families' intricate relationships

07.02 Attacks on Egyptian checkpoints signal escalation in Isis capabilities

07.02 Islamic State threatens to topple Hamas in Gaza Strip in video statement

07.01 A Paradox of American Religion: Diversity Brings Tolerance [Obvious countries should learn from this!]

07.01 The United Nations in a Post-Nation World

07.01 Prime Minister Signals Greece May Accept Bailout Terms

07.01 The Hard Work of Taking Apart Post-Work Fantasy

07.01 Iran's nuclear program may have cost the country $500 billion or more

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.

You can also mail a check to:
Baltimore News Network, Inc.
P.O. Box 42581
Baltimore, MD 21284-2581
Google
This site Web
  Print view: Why We Can't Trust the WSJ's ''Opinion'' Section
MEDIA CRITICISM:

Why We Can't Trust the WSJ's "Opinion" Section

The Wall Street Journal's failure to edit Karl Rove's misleading column on taxes is a case in point.

by Alice Cherbonnier
Sunday, 5 December 2010
Does the Society of Professional Journalists' Code of Ethics' first principle, that "deliberate distortion is never permissible," apply to writers, but not editors?

Where can the public turn today for accurate reporting? It used to be said that the Wall Street Journal's news reporting was impeccable because the power elite who read it would never forgive it for providing false information. Even those not among that exalted universe also once counted on the WSJ, especially during the pre-Murdoch era. This is not to say that the WSJ's editorial and opinion pages were similarly stellar back then, but since it was understood the paper had a certain viewpoint (pro-business, anti-tax, laissez-faire), one expected the articles on those pages to contain cherry-picked facts; after all, that's what such sections are for. At the least, though, one could believe the facts themselves—however they may have been twisted or misinterpreted to make a point—were solid, not squishy.

The Code of Ethics of the Society of Professional Journalists lays out a journalist's responsibilities. Among them: " Deliberate distortion is never permissible." Admittedly this Code of Ethics is voluntary, as there is no licensing or policing of journalists or columnists, nor is there any requirement for a particular sort of education or experience. Journalists must police themselves, and the public's job is to slam them when they don't.

Consider this column as such a slam, then. Let us take as a case in point the column by Karl Rove called "Nancy Pelosi's Unwelcome Christmas Gift," published on page A17 of the WSJ's opinion section on Thurs., Dec. 2. We've come to expect Karl Rove's writings to be unsatisfactory, but this one breaks new ground for disingenuousness. What were the WSJ's editors thinking when they published this? Did they even read it before they sent it out to millions of readers? Someone did: there's a "teaser" highlighting one of Rove's absurd assertions: "A couple earning $80,000 could lose hundreds per month if the Bush tax rates aren't extended."

Rove's beef is that Nancy Pelosi is insisting that the Obama tax cuts for those who earn under $250,000 a year should stay in place, but wants to see a rate hike on the portion of a taxpayer's taxable income that exceeds that amount. Rove leaves out the italicized information. He darkly warns us that "Congress could go home [for the holidays] without stopping the largest tax increase in the nation's history." Say what? The "increase" would be for only the top bracket, and it still would come nowhere near the top rate paid earlier in our history (up to 91%; now it's only 35%).

Rove fails to include essential facts needed to understand the U.S. Tax Code (contrary to the SPJ Code of Ethics: "[Journalists] should not oversimplify or highlight incidents out of context.") He omits the fact that every single taxpayer pays the same tax rate at every step in the Tax Code. The Tax Rate Tables at the end of the link show clearly that every other taxpayer—including Rupert Murdoch, George Soros and Karl Rove—is subject to a mere 10% tax on the first $8,350 of taxable income (if filing as a single person). We're all subject to the same rates every step of the way. We all benefited from the Obama tax cuts, and under the Pelosi plan we will all retain all of them, except for the taxable income over the highest income threshhold.

Rove also omits mention of a huge tax benefit given to all taxpayers, but which disproportionately benefits the wealthy: capital gains income is subject to a piddling 15% tax rate.

Where were the WSJ editors in all this? Surely they have access to telephones, e-mail and fax machines so that they can query Rove and other op-ed contributors about their omissions, misstatements and flat-out lies. Or are these editors (Paul A. Gigot is the WSJ editorial page editor and Daniel Henninger is deputy editor) following the trend of their peers at other U.S. newspapers—of publishing op-ed submissions and syndicated material without providing any editorial input? The reader is then left to figure out whether the information is worthy, because the editors have abdicated their responsibility. Does the Society of Professional Journalists' Code of Ethics' first principle, that "deliberate distortion is never permissible," apply to writers, but not editors?

Look at what happens when the gate-keepers and vetters of information—editors—fail to edit: opinion pieces that should never have been published are circulated world-wide, and quoted by others as if they're fact.

Rove's "Christmas Gift" column got 564 comments (as of Dec. 3) on the WSJ website, but no one can post a comment unless he or she is a WSJ subscriber. Readers of the web version of Rove's column may wade through these comments, and in so doing they may be able to ferret out the full facts from among some wild assertions—tamed somewhat by the WSJ's laudable requirement that those posting comments must use their real names.

But what about the rest of the public? Why, they get served Rove's disingenuous tripe for breakfast on the cable and radio talk shows--with much hype and derision and incivility thrown in for entertainment value.

Anyone who wonders why this country appears to be an intellectual and brutal wasteland needs to trace the "supply chain" of information to the source: the editors at the Wall Street Journal and other "mainstream" media.


Alice Cherbonnier is the Managing Editor of the Baltimore Chronicle.



Copyright © 2010 The Baltimore News Network. All rights reserved.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

Baltimore News Network, Inc., sponsor of this web site, is a nonprofit organization and does not make political endorsements. The opinions expressed in stories posted on this web site are the authors' own.

This story was published on December 5, 2010.
 


Public Service Ads: