Newspaper logo  
 
 
Print view: It's time to end "wealthfare"
ECONOMIC ANALYSIS:

It’s time to end “wealthfare”

by Gerald E. Scorse

The estimated annual revenue losses from special exclusions, exemptions, deductions, credits, deferrals, and preferential tax rates in federal income tax law stand at over $1.5 trillion.

In 1996, making good on a shrewd political promise, President Clinton ended "welfare as we know it." In 2017, battered by election losses, the Democratic Party should double down on a far bigger reform: ending ”wealthfare” as we know it.

The mission couldn't begin at a worse time, or a better time. The triumphant GOP, trifecta in hand, is off in its usual direction. The party is giddy at the prospect of handing another huge tax cut to the rich, including the elimination of an estate tax that affects less than one-third of one percent of all Americans.

If the idea of making the rich richer sticks in your craw, you're not alone. Americans of all political stripes have had it up to here with a rigged system, and nothing says rigged louder than ”wealthfare.”

"Welfare as we know it" met its end because Everybody Just Knew the money went to people who didn't deserve it. ”Wealthfare” has reached its apotheosis because Everybody Just Knows the money goes to people who do deserve it. They're all supposed masters of the universe, hardworking, hard-driving job creators; the rest of us, awestruck, can only properly show our gratitude by showering them with more money. We do this in myriad ways, most blatantly with tax expenditures.

The Tax Policy Center (TPC) defines tax expenditures (a.k.a. tax breaks) as "the estimated revenue losses from special exclusions, exemptions, deductions, credits, deferrals, and preferential tax rates in federal income tax law." For fiscal 2018, the Office of Management and Budget estimates those losses at more than $1.5 trillion, slightly more than the amount paid in individual income taxes in 2015. Putting it another way, the Treasury will lose more revenue in fiscal 2018 from tax breaks than it took in from personal income taxes in 2015.

All Americans love tax breaks and benefit at least minimally (e.g., anybody who files a tax return is entitled to an exemption and a standard deduction). Small potatoes aside, ”wealthfare” flows overwhelmingly to the top.

According to a TPC analysis, the top 1 percent of the income hierarchy receive 32 percent of all benefits from itemized deductions; even more, the same 1 percent receive over 62 percent of the benefits from preferential rates on capital gains, dividends and related preferences.

Lower rates on capital income than labor income are the biggest single driver of income inequality.

Lower rates on capital income than labor income are the biggest single driver of income inequality. Modest moves by President Obama to raise capital-gains taxes for those making upwards of $200,000 were enough by themselves to reduce such inequality for the first time in years. Now, of course, a GOP-controlled Congress could well do away with Obama's actions (all in the supremely ironic, "alternative fact" name of "tax reform").

These few paragraphs barely scratched the surface of “wealthfare." Here are two books that dig far deeper, without ever mentioning the word:

Dean Baker, Rigged: How Globalization and the Rules of the Modern Economy Were Structured to Make the Rich Richer; James Kwak, Economism: Bad Economics and the Rise of Inequality.

Baker's book speaks to "an enormous upward redistribution of income in the United States in the last four decades... [This] was not the result of globalization and the natural workings of the market. Rather it was the result of conscious policies that were designed to put downward pressure on the wages of ordinary workers while protecting and enhancing the incomes of those at the top."

Kwak writes that bright-eyed collegians, hungry for answers, too often take as gospel the elegant graphs and theorems of Economics 101. They become easy prey for a central belief of supply-side economics: the virtue of "reducing the tax burden for the very wealthy." That's no problem at all, given "the particular zeal politicians have for reducing or eliminating taxes on investment income--money you earn by sitting around and watching your assets grow."

Taken together, the books make a compelling case for pulling back from individual-centered ”wealthfare” and putting the money instead toward the common good (infrastructure, for instance).

At this point I'm proud to introduce Sheryl J. Grana, a professor at the University of Minnesota and a fierce "wealthfare” critic . You'll meet her at the end of the following comments thread to a recent article on the website Truthout.

Barry: It is well-known that great wealth [and the trans-generational passing of such wealth] undermines democracy. It really is about time to demand that the rich, who have benefited most by our economic system, pay [their fair share]. Re-asserting inheritance taxes on estates over $5MM and increasing long-term capital gains rates to at least that of ordinary income would be a good start....

Gerald: Re: estate taxes, the phrase "death taxes" has unfortunately turned the majority of Americans against them; this has been a huge framing victory for the right, especially of course for the rich...

Josh: Framing of the "death tax" is akin to the framing of welfare. If only equivalent statistics of ”wealthfare” could be exposed. About 10 years ago, my freshman sociology professor drilled into the class that "wealthfare” costs 7 times that of welfare. I can only imagine that the difference has increased.

Gerald: Love the term "wealthfare,” kudos to your sociology professor. I've heard "welfare for the rich" before, but not ”wealthfare”: much catchier.

Josh: A professor each and every incoming freshmen, let alone upperclassman, would duly benefit from, Dr. Sheryl J. Grana relentlessly seizes your attention with subject matter, perspective, and the skills of a seasoned orator...


Copyright 2017 Gerald E. Scorse. Gerald E. Scorse helped pass the bill requiring basis reporting for capital gains. He writes on taxes..


Copyright © 2017 The Baltimore News Network. All rights reserved.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

Baltimore News Network, Inc., sponsor of this web site, is a nonprofit organization and does not make political endorsements. The opinions expressed in stories posted on this web site are the authors' own.

This story was published on February 14, 2017.

 
Local Gov’t Stories, Events

Ref. : Civic Events

Ref. : Arts & Education Events

Ref. : Public Service Notices

Travel
Books, Films, Arts & Education

02.26 DeVos to Conservative Conference: I Will Replace the Bush-Obama Failed Ideas with My Own Failed Ideas

Letters

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Health Care & Environment

02.27 TRUMPCARE VS. OBAMACARE

02.27 Only China Can Save the Planet [Republicans cede renewable energy dominance to China, as if only fossil energy has worth. Could they be more stupid?]

02.27 With Obamacare in jeopardy, California considers going it alone with 'single-payer' system [with population larger than Canada, California could achieve better single-payer efficiencies than Canada's, with even greater efficiency when more states join in a common insurance market]

02.26 Windfarms aren’t the real reason energy bills are rising. Blame the free market

02.26 Food aid from warehouse to plate: fighting South Sudan’s famine – in pictures

02.26 Scott Pruitt vows to slash climate and water pollution regulations at CPAC [another immoral idiot speaks]

02.25 Revealed: thousands of children at London schools breathe toxic air [you can't see the most dangerous pollution, the particles are too small which makes them dangerous]

02.24 OMG measurements of Greenland give us a glimpse of future sea rise

02.24 Dutch minister calls on UK to join safe abortion fund after Trump ban

02.23 BREAKING: Exxon to Leave Up to 3.6 Billion Barrels of Tar Sands/Oil Sands in the Ground [Yay!]

02.23 Lancet Study on Life Expectancy by 2030 Confirms Poor US Performance

02.23 Climate scientists face harassment, threats and fears of 'McCarthyist attacks' [sociopathic behavior...]

02.23 The Case for a Fracking Ban

News Media Matters

02.26 Spurned Reporters should dump Trump Briefings, turn to Investigative Journalism

02.26 Revealed: how US billionaire helped to back Brexit [and Trump] [at what point is the label "traitor" apropriate?]

02.25 Donald Trump press ban: Guardian, BBC and CNN denied access to briefing

Daily: FAIR Blog
The Daily Howler

US Politics, Policy & 'Culture'

02.26 The Immigration Facts Donald Trump Doesn’t Like

02.26 'Incredibly Disappointing': Democrats Choose Tom Perez to Head Party [not changing is not the answer; can a party taking large campaign donations from healthcare companies ever support price-controlled single-payer?]

02.26 Trump national security adviser wants to avoid term 'radical Islamic terrorism', sources say [McMaster seems an unusually sane member of Trump's administration]

02.25 Wanted: Three Principled Republicans to Save America From Trump

02.25 REPUBLICANS ACCUSE VOTERS OF USING TOWN HALLS TO EXPRESS THEMSELVES

02.25 Resistance Recess Puts Congress on Notice for Supporting Trump’s Agenda

02.25 Steve Bannon: Trump is 'maniacally focused' on executing promises [videos; will increasingly unregulated and immoral capitalism save us?]

02.25 Donald Trump vows to 'get the bad people out' of US – as it happened

Justice Matters

02.26 The story of the week is Trump, Russia and the FBI. The rest is a distraction

02.26 Hate Crime Is Feared as 2 Indian Engineers Are Shot in Kansas [two foreigners walk into a red state bar...]

02.25 White House confirms conversation with FBI about Trump and Russia

High Crimes?
Economics, Crony Capitalism

02.25 Just as neoliberalism is finally on its knees, so too is the left

02.24 Michael Hudson: Why Failing to Solve Personal Debt and Polarization Will Usher in a New Dark Age

International

02.27 How Russia Is Using Oil Deals To Secure Its Influence In The Middle East [countries should get off of fossil fuels so the world can breathe]

02.27 Infographic: Here’s How the Global GDP Is Divvied Up

02.27 Twilight of the Technocrats? [caring for people and morals have to become prime factors!]

02.27 THE LONG HISTORY OF DEPORTATION SCARE TACTICS AT THE U.S.-MEXICO BORDER [why can't we have altruistic policy to help people avoid becoming refugees? perhaps it is bad governments that should be helped...or punished. is U.S. drug policy the root problem?]

02.26 HOW PETER THIEL’S PALANTIR HELPED THE NSA SPY ON THE WHOLE WORLD [technology East Germany's STASI would have loved!]

02.25 CHINA’S NORTH KOREA PROBLEM

02.25 TRUMP, PUTIN, AND THE NEW COLD WAR

02.25 Marine Le Pen refuses to be questioned by French police

02.24 A Global Counter-Trump Movement Is Taking Shape

02.24 UN: $4.4bn needed to prevent 'catastrophe' of famine

02.24 Kim Jong-nam killed by VX nerve agent, say Malaysian police

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.

You can also mail a check to:
Baltimore News Network, Inc.
P.O. Box 42581
Baltimore, MD 21284-2581
Google
This site Web
 

Public Service Ads: