Newspaper logo  
   Congress Takes Aim At USA PATRIOT Act

ACLU Calls Move Giant Win for Civil Liberties:

Congress Takes Aim At USA PATRIOT Act

Special to the Chronicle

The House amendment to limit federal "sneak and peek" delayed notification search warrants--which passed by a vote of 309 to 118, with 113 Republicans voting in favor--still has to clear the Senate and the President before it becomes law.
WASHINGTON, July 23 - In response to the first clear--and overwhelmingly bipartisan--congressional repudiation of anti-privacy and anti-civil liberties provisions in the USA PATRIOT Act last night, the American Civil Liberties Union today called the move "a huge win" and urged Congress to follow it with further action to restore Americans' liberties.

"Congress took a courageous stand last night in its response to widespread public concern over civil liberties - hopefully this is the first trickle in a flood of PATRIOT fixes," said Laura W. Murphy, Director of the ACLU Washington Legislative Office. "Congress is beginning to respond to what regular Americans have been saying at backyard barbecues and across their kitchen tables for months now: we can - and must - be both safe and free."

Specifically, Congress agreed-- by an extraordinary margin-- to an amendment to this year's Commerce, Justice and State funding bill that would bar federal law enforcement from implementing "sneak and peek" delayed notification search warrants, pursuant to a provision in the USA PATRIOT Act. Conservative Rep. C.L. "Butch" Otter (R-ID) offered the amendment, which passed by a vote of 309 to 118, with 113 Republicans voting in favor. The amendment still has to clear the Senate and the President before it becomes law.

The Otter Amendment, according to the ACLU, is "the first unequivocal indication that lawmakers are taking seriously a broad, grassroots backlash against excessive government powers, which has grown exponentially in the past several months." To date, at least 142 communities and three states, encompassing more than 16 million people, have passed pro-civil liberties resolutions that speak out against the PATRIOT Act, many of which call for specific fixes to the bill.

The Otter Amendment would effectively prohibit any implementation of section 213 of the PATRIOT Act, which permits federal agents to obtain sneak and peek warrants under a very low evidentiary standard, making them far easier to get than before the bill was passed. Sneak and peek or "black bag" warrants, as they are also called, allow agents to search homes, confiscate certain types of property and essentially "bug" computers, without notifying the subject of the search that it is happening for an often indeterminate amount of time.

Critics of the measure say that it violates both the intent and principle of Fourth Amendment protections against unreasonable searches and seizures, and the long-held "knock and announce" warrant requirement, which is meant to give subjects of a search the opportunity to challenge errors in the warrant such as a wrong address or mistaken name.

"Although we applaud Rep. Otter and his fellow patriots, there is now more to be done," said Timothy Edgar, an ACLU Legislative Counsel. "The PATRIOT Act is replete with similar unnecessary and un-American surveillance, detention and investigative powers that must be repealed before we can really begin to restore civil liberties protections to where they need to be in America."

For more information on the USA PATRIOT Act's provisions, visit

Copyright © 2003 The Baltimore Chronicle and The Sentinel. All rights reserved. We invite your comments, criticisms and suggestions.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle and Sentinel content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

This story was published on July 23, 2003.
7.23Rep. Cardin to Travel to Guantanamo Bay to Review Status of Terror Suspects
7.14Woodberry Woods Gains Second National Recognition
7.13Credit Union to Participate in the Federal Home Loan Bank First Time Homebuyers Program
7.13 New Phase of Gwynns Falls Trail Opens
7.13Presbyterians Name New Leader
7.13Hampden Showcases Youth Media
7.12Community Activists Find Their Efforts Trumped by Developers Aided by City Government
7.12Garden Center Blooming in Hampden
6.10MTA Rate Increases Go In Effect June 30
6.10Liquor: The Other Drug
6.4City Council Unanimously Condemns ‘Patriot Act’
7.12Letters to the Editor
Open Letters:
6.4To Baltimore City Comptroller Pratt
7.12Travel: Sicily, Crossroads of Invaders
7.12What happened to the 56 men who signed the Declaration of Independence?
7.12Bottom Floor Concert Series Moves to Patterson Arts Center
7.12Anonymous Words of Wisdom
7.12Books: Sports Figures and Race: Overcoming Obstacles
7.12Book: Author Takes the High Road in JFK Bio
7.24NYT Flaks for Government by Omitting Three Critical Words
7.15France Bashers Ignorant of American History
7.12Hugo Chavez Is Crazy!
7.12Poll Finds Major Polls Distort Results by How They Frame Questions
7.12Human Rights Watch Calls on Saudi Government to Make Real Reforms Instead of Mounting a Media Image Campaign
7.25"Winning the War on Credibility"
7.22Even with Weapons, Hussein Was No Threat
7.16Is Fraud a High Crime or Misdemeanor?
7.14Lawlessness in Iraq and the Failure of Unilateralism
7.12To an American Friend
7.14Local Bar Abruptly Cancels Palestinian Aid Concert
7.14Charm City's Revolution Zone
7.14Baltimore Hosts ‘Peace Palace for Collective Meditation’
7.12Powell Denies Intelligence Failure In Buildup To War, But Evidence Doesn’t Hold Up
7.12It’s Not That College Students Are Stupid; They’re Willfully Ignorant
7.12Conservative Conundrum
7.12Nader Blasts Plutocrats, Bush & Iraq War: Calls for ‘Congress Watch Locals’
7.12Religious and Advocacy Organizations Establish ‘Global Benchmarks’ for Corporations Worldwide
7.2Of Mice and (Con) Men
6.22The 'Crime' of Exercising Free Speech at Baltimore's Inner Harbor
7.31Greens to Run Presidential Candidate in 2004, But Who?
7.23Daniel Pipes nomination stalled in committee
7.23Congress Takes Aim At USA PATRIOT Act
7.14Bush's Wasted Trip to Africa
7.12“The Matrix,” a French Philosopher, and the Events of September 11
7.13The Bi-national State: The Wolf Shall Dwell With The Lamb
7.12Ballot-Tampering in the 21st Century
7.12Why Bioterrorism is America’s Greatest Threat
7.12Cardin Introduces Bipartisan Bill to Eliminate Medicare Late Enrollment Penalty
7.12Weapons of Mass Deception
6.27Dean or Kucinich: Which is Better for Progressives?
SCREED: news major media ‘tries to hide’
Websites We Like!
Analysis & Perspective

Public Service Ads: