Newspaper logo  
 
 
   Conservative Conundrum

VIEWPOINT:

Conservative Conundrum

by Sheldon Richman

When you hear a politician talk about cutting the costs of a service provided in the private sector, run in the other direction. It means price controls, and nothing is more devastating and disruptive than price controls.
Conservatives become more inscrutable every day. They spend half their time praising the federal government for its miracles in Iraq (and, if they get their way, in Iran) and the other half of their time ridiculing the Democrats for thinking that the same federal government can provide medical insurance for everyone.

Sean Hannity, the hottest conservative property these days on radio and cable television, did just this one evening in May on his Fox television program. First, he raved about the government’s efficacy in Iraq; then he bashed the Democrats for thinking that the government, “which never gets anything right,” can become everyone’s health insurer.

Which is it, conservatives?

There are excellent reasons for rejecting any attempt by the government to take over health insurance. Politicians will begin by making grand promises, but they will end up creating shortages and shoddy medical services and imposing restrictions on people seeking those services. Just examine the various plans being floated by the would-be Democratic presidential candidates. Sen. John Kerry, for example, promises to cut costs while extending coverage to nearly everyone. When you hear a politician talk about cutting the costs of a service provided in the private sector, run in the other direction. It means price controls, and nothing is more devastating and disruptive than price controls. Moreover, nothing better shows a politician’s ignorance of basic economics.

The price system is essential for coordinating supply and demand. It is what helps prevent unfulfilled demand and unwanted supply. Prices are signals to entrepreneurs that carry vital information about what people want and what resources are available. Socialist economies cannot function because they either abolish prices or so badly distort them that they cannot perform their role.

Government control of prices is a policy deliberately aimed at distorting those signals. Unsurprisingly, they wreak havoc in any market. Where there are price ceilings, there are shortages and shoddy goods and services. Remember that, when you hear a candidate promise to control the costs of medical services and insurance.

Another problem with these proposals is that they misconstrue the purpose for insurance. Were it not for the daffy tax code, people would use medical insurance only to prevent being wiped out financially by a catastrophic illness or injury. Using insurance for every routine doctor visit is like using auto insurance for oil changes. It’s not worth it—unless you can get someone else to pay the premiums. That’s what medical insurance is designed to do today. (People still pay the premiums; they’re just well hidden.)

So the conservatives are correct. It is futile for government to try to make medical care widely available. Free markets are the best route to that destination. (Too bad President Bush does not know this.) Then why do conservatives think the government can do something more complex, such as turning Iraq into a modern, enlightened polity? They seem to think the American military can work magic. It can’t.

Using insurance for every routine doctor visit is like using auto insurance for oil changes. It’s not worth it—unless you can get someone else to pay the premiums.

Societies are so complex that no one can plan them, not even the brilliant civilian and military minds that run the US government. If the Iraqis are going to have society in which individual rights (including property rights) are respected, in which the rule of law prevails, and in which power is strictly limited, they are going to have to discover those things for themselves. Liberalism (in the original pro-freedom sense) cannot be force-fed. Attempting it will only breed resentment and resistance. The US government is already seen as an occupier in Iraq. This will only get worse.

The conservatives don’t get it. Years ago the quintessential conservative columnist, George Will, pointed out a conundrum: if conservatives say that government is incompetent when it comes to controlling prices and wages, who will believe them when they say that the government can do things such as overthrow Castro? (This was written when Saddam Hussein was still a US ally.)

We can turn that question around: if conservatives insist that the government can build a nation in Iraq, who will believe them when they say the government can’t run the health-care system?


Sheldon Richman is senior fellow at The Future of Freedom Foundation in Fairfax, Va., author of Tethered Citizens: Time to Repeal the Welfare State, and editor of Ideas on Liberty magazine.



Copyright © 2003 The Baltimore Chronicle and The Sentinel. All rights reserved. We invite your comments, criticisms and suggestions.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle and Sentinel content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

This story was published on July 12, 2003.
  
LOCAL NEWS
7.14CALENDAR
7.23Rep. Cardin to Travel to Guantanamo Bay to Review Status of Terror Suspects
7.14Woodberry Woods Gains Second National Recognition
7.13Credit Union to Participate in the Federal Home Loan Bank First Time Homebuyers Program
7.13 New Phase of Gwynns Falls Trail Opens
7.13Presbyterians Name New Leader
7.13Hampden Showcases Youth Media
7.12Community Activists Find Their Efforts Trumped by Developers Aided by City Government
7.12Garden Center Blooming in Hampden
6.10MTA Rate Increases Go In Effect June 30
6.10Liquor: The Other Drug
6.4City Council Unanimously Condemns ‘Patriot Act’
LETTERS
7.12Letters to the Editor
Open Letters:
6.4To Baltimore City Comptroller Pratt
ART & ENTERTAINMENT
7.12Travel: Sicily, Crossroads of Invaders
7.12What happened to the 56 men who signed the Declaration of Independence?
7.12Bottom Floor Concert Series Moves to Patterson Arts Center
7.12Anonymous Words of Wisdom
7.12Books: Sports Figures and Race: Overcoming Obstacles
7.12Book: Author Takes the High Road in JFK Bio
NEWS MEDIA CRITIQUE
7.24NYT Flaks for Government by Omitting Three Critical Words
7.15France Bashers Ignorant of American History
7.12Hugo Chavez Is Crazy!
7.12Poll Finds Major Polls Distort Results by How They Frame Questions
7.12Human Rights Watch Calls on Saudi Government to Make Real Reforms Instead of Mounting a Media Image Campaign
EDITORIALS & OP-EDs
7.25"Winning the War on Credibility"
7.22Even with Weapons, Hussein Was No Threat
7.16Is Fraud a High Crime or Misdemeanor?
7.14Lawlessness in Iraq and the Failure of Unilateralism
7.12To an American Friend
SPEAKING OUT
7.14Local Bar Abruptly Cancels Palestinian Aid Concert
7.14Charm City's Revolution Zone
7.14Baltimore Hosts ‘Peace Palace for Collective Meditation’
7.12Powell Denies Intelligence Failure In Buildup To War, But Evidence Doesn’t Hold Up
7.12It’s Not That College Students Are Stupid; They’re Willfully Ignorant
7.12Conservative Conundrum
7.12Nader Blasts Plutocrats, Bush & Iraq War: Calls for ‘Congress Watch Locals’
7.12Religious and Advocacy Organizations Establish ‘Global Benchmarks’ for Corporations Worldwide
7.2Of Mice and (Con) Men
6.22The 'Crime' of Exercising Free Speech at Baltimore's Inner Harbor
(INTER)NATIONAL
7.31Greens to Run Presidential Candidate in 2004, But Who?
7.23Daniel Pipes nomination stalled in committee
7.23Congress Takes Aim At USA PATRIOT Act
7.14Bush's Wasted Trip to Africa
7.12“The Matrix,” a French Philosopher, and the Events of September 11
7.13The Bi-national State: The Wolf Shall Dwell With The Lamb
7.12Ballot-Tampering in the 21st Century
7.12Why Bioterrorism is America’s Greatest Threat
7.12Cardin Introduces Bipartisan Bill to Eliminate Medicare Late Enrollment Penalty
7.12Weapons of Mass Deception
6.27Dean or Kucinich: Which is Better for Progressives?
FROM OTHER SITES
SCREED: news major media ‘tries to hide’
Websites We Like!
Analysis & Perspective

Public Service Ads: