Newspaper logo  
 
 
   Shariah Law in Nigeria--and in Texas and Tennessee

MEDIA CRITICISM:

Shariah Law in Nigeria—and in Texas and Tennessee

by David Flores

Will the freeing of Nigeria’s Amina Lawal—ta token gesture of humanity and compassion—cause Americans to reconsider their own obsession with capital punishment?
BALTIMORE, 10/17/03—On September 26, the newspapers brought us the joyful news that Amina Lawal, the Nigerian woman who was sentenced to death for giving birth out of wedlock, has been cleared of all charges and allowed to go home. The original sentence had been imposed in March of 2002 by an Islamic court, acting in accordance with its reading of "Shariah," a very strict interpretation of Islamic law.

Lawal's legal victory was also a victory for global human rights. The young Nigerian mother had become something of a cause célèbre since the original verdict and penalty were handed down, and the Islamic court's reversal in the face of nearly universal condemnation gives fresh hope to those activists and organizations around the planet who would seek to better our world by shinning a bright spotlight upon its injustices.

Who can deny that the Shariah court's sensible reversal is a welcome and needed victory for humanity and common decency, coming as it did just six months after the depressing spectacle of our own President's steadfast refusal to back down from an illegal war against Iraq--a crime that was carried out in the face of even more widespread popular condemnation? It is true that, in the latter case, thousands of good people lost their lives, while in the former, only one was spared. Nonetheless, men and women of conscience are grateful whenever popular indignation manages to soften the hearts of the powerful and effect the correction of even one injustice.

With Lawal spirited away to the safety of her father's house, the question that remains now is whether this token gesture of humanity and compassion will cause Americans to reconsider their own obsession with capital punishment. Will we undertake a rethinking of our deeply ingrained culture of revenge, our overwhelming support for the state-sanctioned taking of another person's life, our wholehearted embrace of the primitive and simplistic justice embodied in the extracting of an eye for an eye? Or will we, instead, persist in holding to the myth that the "just" and "righteous" death sentences that are meted out in our own courtrooms bear little, if any, similarity to the barbarous judgment that nearly cost Lawal her life, and almost rendered her two-year-old son an orphan.

Unfortunately, given the pathetic state of America's fourth estate, it is unlikely that the press will take this joyful turn of events as the point of departure for a campaign to educate the people about the racial and economic injustices that are inherent in the practice of capital punishment. It remains unlikely that our nation’s editors, producers, reporters and anchors will begin a national dialogue and reconsideration of the morality of the death penalty. Most people in America will almost certainly continue to labor under the false pretense that the killing of a man or woman in a Texas prison is just and fair in the way that the near killing of Amina Lawal in a Nigerian prison was not.

America is not Nigeria, after all, and is it not self-evident that only a barbarous people would think it just to sentence a nursing mother to death? Is it not plain to see that only a people wholly lacking in compassion would choose to carry out a young mother’s execution the minute her child no longer required suckling?

Given the pathetic state of America's fourth estate, it is unlikely that the press will take this joyful turn of events in Nigeria as the point of departure for a campaign to educate the people about the racial and economic injustices that are inherent in the practice of capital punishment in the US.

Yes, it is self-evident, and it is plain to see. But unfortunately, it is also precisely what George W. Bush and Albert Gore (to take two representative American legislators) would have done had they found themselves in the same position as the Nigerian jurists. I realize this claim may seem far-fetched, but one need only review Bush and Gore’s statements to the press to find this conclusion borne out quite explicitly. One need only examine the death penalty debate (the death penalty monologue, actually, there was no debate) as it played itself out in the 2000 presidential campaign to confirm this ugly fact. At that time, both men were routinely questioned about their position vis à vis the death penalty and both candidates unfailingly proclaimed themselves staunch promoters of the practice.

But a willingness, even eagerness, to send human beings off to the death chamber was apparently not, in itself, good enough, and so the press turned the heat up a notch. Each man was then asked whether he would carry out the execution of a pregnant woman who had been sentenced to die. In both cases the men produced answers that betrayed no compromise of their unwavering support for capital punishment.

In answering the question of whether he would order the execution of a pregnant woman, George W. Bush merely preempted the logic of the Nigerian Shariah court. Our current President explained, as reported on July 17, 2000, that he would stay the execution until after her baby had been born, "because there's a second life involved." . [He did not, to my knowledge, say whether he would have her whisked off to the gas chamber the very next day, or allow her some time to recover.]

Yet, as distasteful and un-compassionate as the compassionate conservative's answer was, its hideousness paled in comparison with candidate Gore's incredible remarks. Initially the Democratic presidential hopeful responded to interviewer Tim Russert's hypothetical by proclaiming himself perplexed: "Well, I don't know what the circumstances would be in that situation. I would, you know, it's an interesting fact situation. I'd want to think about it..." (“Meet the Press,” 07/16/00) And one would have hoped that Gore would leave it at that, go home, and rethink his commitment to capital punishment. But instead, the very next day, having enjoyed the benefit of an entire evening to meditate on the question, to discuss it with his advisers, and to concoct an answer that might best satisfy the concerns of both pro-death penalty and pro-choice voters, Gore amended his original remarks by issuing a statement of truly Kafkaesque absurdity and unbelievably macabre logic: "the principle of a woman's right to choose governs in that case."

In other words, in contrast to Bush, who responded to the aforementioned query by proclaiming that he would show Republican pro-life compassion and wait for the child to be born before shuttling his mother off to the gas chamber, Albert Gore reassured the public of his Democratic commitment to abortion rights by proclaiming that he would allow the prisoner herself to choose whether to put off the execution until after the birth of her baby, or, if she so preferred, to march right on in to the death chamber and get it over with forthwith.

Incredibly, and inexplicably, the mere notion that this distasteful and extreme hypothetical might tend to undermine the case for the death penalty itself was never broached by the candidates or by the mainstream press. As far as America and her Republican and Democratic candidate for President were concerned, it was not a question even worth considering. It simply didn't fit in to the equation at all. And that, dear reader, is justice, sanity, and compassion in contemporary America.

It’s hard to say at what point the death penalty joined the Cuban embargo, corporate farm subsidies, and unfettered economic and military aid to Israel as "third rail," untouchable issues in American politics—and in American media. It is even more difficult to understand why it did. But what is certain is that, just as with those other three abominations, our unquestioning reverence for the death penalty weakens this nation, it corrupts us, and it robs us of our moral standing and authority in the world.


David Flores works in the language department at Loyola College. He maintains a blog of his work.


Copyright © 2003 The Baltimore Chronicle and The Sentinel. All rights reserved. We invite your comments, criticisms and suggestions.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle and Sentinel content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

This story was published on October 20, 2003.
  
Local Stories, Events

Ref. : Civic Events

Ref. : Arts & Education Events

Ref. : Public Service Notices

Books, Films, Arts & Education

06.14 The Trump administration is waging a quiet war on education

06.11 Underpaid Adjunct Professors Sleep in Cars and Rely on Public Aid [The disease of rapacious-capitalism infects the education system]

Letters

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Health Care & Environment

06.17 Oil companies double down on plastics as public outcry grows [Obscene!]

06.17 Ocasio-Cortez: "We’re Going to Fight to Repeal the Hyde Amendment"

06.15 'The Changes Are Really Accelerating': Alaska at Record Warm While Greenland Sees Major Ice Melt

06.15 So much plastic is being made that "recycling has no impact" [Non-recyclable plastic must be made illegal to manufacture, use]

06.15 Climate crisis: aviation industry hears clamour for electric planes

06.15 We must transform our lives and values to save this burning planet [Increased ice melt in polar latitudes has been disguising reality in the middle latitudes. This effect will soon be replaced by record heat as ice volume and seasonal melting increasingly declines.]

06.15 This all-male council in Texas just voted to ban abortion [1:59 video; Bad assumptions foment ignorant actions...]

06.14 The Trans Mountain pipeline is a disaster – but Trudeau can make it right

06.14 The Pentagon emits more greenhouse gases than Portugal, study finds

06.14 Climate crisis: Alaska is melting and it’s likely to accelerate global heating

06.13 Chemical companies at centre of Guardian's Cancer Town series face state legal action [7:56 video]

06.12 'This is not a "what if" story': Tokyo braces for the earthquake of a century

06.12 Plant Species Have Been Disappearing 500 Times Faster Than Normal, Thanks to Humans

06.12 Atmospheric carbon levels are leaping. We can't afford more years like this

06.12 Politics as Usual and Planetary Destruction

06.12 Most 'meat' in 2040 will not come from dead animals, says report

06.11 Forest twice size of UK destroyed in decade for big consumer brands – report

06.11 Twice as many plants have gone extinct than birds, mammals, and amphibians combined

06.11 NOAA forecasts very large ‘dead zone’ for Gulf of Mexico

06.10 Conservatives should change how they think about global warming. I did [Another crisis issue conservatives won't acknowledge...]

06.10 Scottish Power to build vast battery to improve wind energy supply [Who won't understand this?]

06.10 Greenpeace activists board BP oil rig as it is towed out to sea [Fossil fuel company conduct should be illegal...]

06.09 Racism as a Public Health Crisis

06.08 GreenWay Reaches 100 EV Fast Chargers In Poland!

06.07 Single-Payer Reform—“Medicare for All”

06.07 Purpose in Life Protects Against Cognitive Decline Among Older Adults

News Media Matters

06.15 China's Expanding Media Dominance in Africa

Daily: FAIR Blog
The Daily Howler

US Politics, Policy & 'Culture'

06.17 Climate change leadership would create a new 'American century' [We must incentivize the strategic good, again, before it's too late.]

06.17 Jon Stewart takes aim at McConnell in continued fight for 9/11 victim compensation fund [2:56 C-SPAN video]

06.17 Drug Cop Worth $400 Million After Bets on Brooklyn Real Estate [A better role-model than Trump or Kushner!]

06.15 Hard Times in the Imperial Valley

06.15 Ro Khanna Forces Beltway Bandit to Refund Millions From Price Gouging

06.15 White House physicist sought aid of rightwing thinktank to challenge climate science [When your President is a quack he naturally surrounds himself with sycophants]

06.14 Do Your Jobs: Sick and Dying, They Brought Themselves Down Here to Speak - To No One

06.14 The Case for Reparations [5:31 video]

06.14 Bernie Sanders just made a brilliant defense of democratic socialism

06.14 Texas Progressive Jessica Cisneros Announces Primary Challenge to Unseat "Trump's Favorite Democrat" in Congress

06.13 Elizabeth Warren Has a Plan for Everything — Except Health Care

06.13 Where do the 2020 Democratic candidates stand on the key issues?

06.13 Hidden Figures Way: Nasa renames street to honor black female mathematicians

06.13 Why are we still pretending 'trickle-down' economics work? [We aren't ‘laffing’ now! In Trump-world all the worst people are celebrated. Ref.: 3:07 Idiocracy Courtroom Scene]

06.13 What’s actually in the Green New Deal, explained with a video [7:30 video]

Justice Matters

06.14 Justice Denied, Delayed, or Done Right? Serious Concerns as Prosecutors Throw Out Charges in Flint Water Crisis Cases [A very flawed prosecution using suspiciously limited evidence has been thrown out, a stronger case will be brought using newly found, voluminous evidence.]

High Crimes

06.17 'Blatant Theft': Netanyahu Unveils Illegal Settlement Named 'Trump Heights' in Occupied Syrian Territory [Great deal: the U.S. gives Israel $Billions every year, and they name an illegal settlement—to be built on Palestinian land—after Trump]

Economics & Corrupt Capitalism

06.15 'Eye-Popping': Analysis Shows Top 1% Gained $21 Trillion in Wealth Since 1989 While Bottom Half Lost $900 Billion [More equality or bring back the guillotines!]

06.13 Even the 1% Know They Aren't Paying Their Fair Share: New Poll Shows 60% of Millionaires Support Warren's Ultra-Wealth Tax

International & Futurism

06.17 Saudi Arabia May Execute Teenager for His Protests — Including When He Was 10 [America's “best ally” is psychopathically insane]

06.17 Why Venezuela Is the Vietnam of Our Time [Powerful, clear writing!]

06.17 US Attacks Russia’s Power Grid; Trump Kept in Dark

06.17 Hopes for climate progress falter with coal still king across Asia [Governments must subsidize very rapid installation of renewable energy to displace all fossil energy—aka DEATH ENERGY—power plants that must be made illegal ASAP]

06.15 Africa’s Lost Kingdoms

06.15 Homophobic and transphobic hate crimes surge in England and Wales

06.15 Extinction Rebellion protesters stop rush-hour traffic in London

06.15 Hong Kong leader suspends extradition bill amid protest pressure [1:37 video]

06.15 The US must stand with the people of Hong Kong [But this attacks Xi's authoritarianism, which Trump is most envious of for himself...]

06.14 As Angus Taylor ducks, weaves and dithers, China zooms past

06.13 What does it mean to be genetically Jewish? [Doing a mental dance with archanery: could a significant number of Russians and Palestinians be intentionally included or excluded as genetically Jewish? And why would Israel do this?]

06.13 Two oil tankers struck in suspected attacks in Gulf of Oman

06.13 Theresa May’s carbon emissions plan will fail if the chancellor remains complacent

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.

You can also mail a check to:
Baltimore News Network, Inc.
P.O. Box 42581
Baltimore, MD 21284-2581
Google
This site Web

Public Service Ads: