Newspaper logo  
   Crises of Democracy


Crises of Democracy

by Dr. Khoren Arisian

No wonder Ralph Waldo Emerson once remarked, in a letter to Thomas Carlyle in the 1830s, about the emerging American character: “We are a little wild here.” Indeed we are. Welcome to Redneck America.
We cannot understand what is really going on in American politics today without a critical and unblinking examination of its enduring religious basis and the theological presuppositions supporting it. Consider President George W. Bush’s current nominee for the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals, Alabama Attorney General William H. Pryor, Jr., who deems it “acceptable to execute the mentally retarded,” replace the Constitution with the Bible, and asserts that, “We derive our rights from God and not from government.”

Since God is more elusive than government, the likelihood of outrageously subjective interpretations of “God’s will” can only run rampant. This has been amply demonstrated in pronouncements by such divinely inspired political stalwarts as John Ashcroft and Tom DeLay. The US government assuredly doesn’t want an Islamic state in Iraq, yet DeLay has openly stated that God has assigned him to promote “a biblical worldview” in how he goes about his political responsibilities as House Majority Leader. Meanwhile, John Ashcroft tells us that “Jesus is our only King,” and Commerce Secretary Don Evans reveals to us that God told George Bush to wage war on Iraq.

Republican stronghold
In May, the New York Times told us that the Republican National Committee—or GOP—is striving for “an Era of Dominance”. It is hardly news anymore, but it is disconcerting nonetheless. The Republican Party is in a buoyant mood since the ‘War on Terrorism,’ as we portentously describe it, is likely to persist indefinitely (if sporadically) and the GOP allegedly is the best equipped to engage with such a challenge. Meanwhile, a sputtering Democratic Party is quickly devolving toward extended minority status.

For the first time in 50 years, Republicans constitute a majority of state legislatures. They dominate no less than three branches of the federal government. In the newspapers we read that the male scions of “boomer” parents are enthusiastically gung-ho about the military establishment. They nearly equate it with the Republican-dominated federal government. Hence, both party and government are deemed to be one: efficient, upright and trustworthy—meriting a 75% approval rating roughly coinciding with that of the president himself.

At the end of May, President Bush signed off on another economically unnecessary tax cut—$350 billion worth—which of course is also a politically pre-emptive act, with the 2004 elections being just 17-18 months away. Mr. Bush also sanctioned an almost trillion-dollar increase in the government’s borrowing capacity, thus adding the same amount to the national debt on which interest is to be paid. Deficits, we are assured, don’t matter anymore, and I dare say, might well outlast the war on terror.

Fueling that conflict is the assumed notorious “axis of evil,” according to Bush. He intoned the phrase against Iraq, Iran and North Korea in a nationally televised address on 20 September, 2001, little more than a week after 9/11.

The first Puritans to arrive on American shores would have approved.

A nation born of Puritanism
In 1630, Massachusetts’ first Royal Governor, John Winthrop, evoked a lasting biblical image, “We shall be as a City upon a Hill, the eyes of all people upon us.” These Puritan immigrants from England soon faced an outbreak of “evil” they felt had to be subdued; in 1636 they launched a war against local “devil worshippers”—the Pequot Indians, who resented the Puritans’ intrusion onto their land.

Clearly possessed by Satan, the natives had to be eliminated, and they were. The Indians’ village was set ablaze; hundreds were killed—either shot, drowned, or sold into slavery.

According to the organiser of the Mayflower expedition, William Bradford, this constituted “a sweet sacrifice to God.” Evildoers, in short, must be either summarily punished or killed. Both would come to pass in Salem in 1692, when fanatical judges saw to it that 19 innocent people were hanged for being possessed by the Devil.

The most Hebraic of the original Protestant sects, the early Puritans—control freaks extraordinaire—believed that church and state should be separate but closely associated and led by the same types of people in either case.

The Puritans’ wars against Native Americans spawned frightful delusions throughout New England. The Puritans’ theology of choice was Calvinism—the elect few predestined by God to success and wealth versus the many predestined to perdition, misery and hell on earth; everyone in effect lived in a state of unrelieved anxiety that consequently instigated a kind of nervous activism. Beginning with the infamous Salem witch-trials of the 1690s, we’ve had periodic political witch-hunts ever since.

In the 1970s Reverend Jerry Falwell publicly concluded, “Satan has mobilized its forces to destroy America.” Such born-again religious fervor ihas been on the rise ever since.

Demonizing the opposition
Wars propagate an us-versus-them mentality. Bush’s aforementioned proclamation on 20 September included his statement that you are either with “us” or with “the terrorists of the world.” No wonder Supreme Court Justice Sandra Day O’Connor off-handedly commented at the time that, “We’re likely to experience more restrictions on personal freedom than has ever been the case in our country.” Did O’Connor suspect or know something the rest of us did not?

No wonder Ralph Waldo Emerson once remarked, in a letter to Thomas Carlyle in the 1830s, about the emerging American character: “We are a little wild here.” Indeed we are. Welcome to Redneck America.

To be “born again” is an evangelical legacy of the Puritan tradition; to be born again is to be an adamant “true believer,” such as that described by author Eric Hoffer. All of which puts me in mind of those secular true believers, the Jacobins of the French Revolution.

When Jacobin leader Robespierre hijacked the people’s Revolution in their name, he corrupted it totally, ushering in a prolonged period of massacres and slaughter—an early symptom of what Alexis de Tocqueville would later term, with his usual uncanny prescience, “a virus of a new and unknown kind”: what in Western culture would morph into genocidal inclination—evil committed in the name of an insane nationalism, ethnic cleansing, or ideology—or, as is increasingly the case these days, in the name of some intolerant, absolutist religious fundamentalism. (Surely Hitlerism and the Holocaust exemplify the first most horrific “virus of a new and unknown kind” in modern times.)

The French revolutionaries were not unlike the English Puritans in one respect. In their mad zeal, they rendered themselves incapable of conceiving the validity of a loyal opposition. None who thought otherwise could be their equal; therefore those who disagreed with them were deemed traitors who had to be eliminated. One could only be 100% for the Jacobins or 100% against them, which prepared the ground for their Reign of Terror in 1793-1794 during which thousands were executed.

Is anything more fatal to humanity than ‘either/or’ thinking? If all who disagree with you are, by definition, irredeemable traitors then no real democracy is possible!

Is anything more fatal to humanity than ‘either/or’ thinking? If all who disagree with you are, by definition, irredeemable traitors then no real democracy is possible! Such a state of affairs, by extension to our own day and time, is what ultimately concerns me about those on the religious and political Right. They typically present themselves as knowing, better than anyone else in the world what we as a nation need to do, impetuously brushing aside questions from, or discussion with, those who differ with them in the slightest.

Democracy anew
The original Puritan settlers of this country in the 1620s were true believers: not radicals but revolutionaries who proved to be religious—and political—killers, among other less lethal attributes. Today’s religious Right are in effect their doctrinal descendants.

It was in the name of a fervent nationalism that the French revolutionaries finally declared war on all of Europe’s great powers. After years of Napoleon’s spectacular victories, France nonetheless collapsed from its imperial reach.

It is in the name of national security, a euphemism for nationalism, that the present administration in Washington is preparing for war without end—in our name, and presumably for our own protection. Our consent is absent, except for that which the Bushies manufacture. Shall we be so naïve as to trust the ethics of their intentions? Yet, it is not their intentions that are at issue, but the likely fatal consequences of the actions that these holy warriors—most of whom have never been in battle—have in mind.

Of late, I’ve been quoting James Madison in public, perhaps the most far-seeing of the founders of what we nostalgically refer to as the American Republic. The American imperium, in Gore Vidal’s view, was born the day the National Security Act was enacted in 1947. Here are Madison’s amazing words, expressed in a letter to Jefferson in 1788 as the Constitution was nearing completion: “There may be a certain degree of danger that a succession of artful and ambitious rulers, may by gradual and well–timed advances, finally erect an independent Government on the subversion of liberty.”

This situation cannot be tolerated much longer. We cannot remain constantly worried and/or somnolent until unpleasant things somehow blow over, allowing us to “return to normal”—an understandable but naive hope.

I believe we are moving toward that end at a fast clip. What was essentially a political vision of presidential dominance in Watergate became quasi-religious with Reagan, and now, insistently, evangelically fundamentalist with the current administration in Washington. This situation cannot be tolerated much longer. We cannot remain constantly worried and/or somnolent until unpleasant things somehow blow over, allowing us to “return to normal”—an understandable but naïve hope.

Right now, therefore, we have to think anew, strategize anew, and act anew on behalf of the entire spectrum of the democratic prospect. We cannot afford to behave like the good Germans of the Nazi Reich.

This article is based on a panel presentation at the New York Society for Ethical Culture on May 28, 2003. Dr. Khoren Arisian is Senior Leader of the New York Society for Ethical Culture. A graduate of Tufts University, he has been director and co-founder of the Ethical Culture School of Adult Education, a member of the Chaplaincy Task Force for the New York Board of Corrections, and a founder of the New York Society’s Prison Reform Task Force.

Copyright © 2003 The Baltimore Chronicle and The Sentinel. All rights reserved. We invite your comments, criticisms and suggestions.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle and Sentinel content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

This story was published on September 18, 2003.
Local Stories, Events

Ref. : Civic Events

Ref. : Arts & Education Events

Ref. : Public Service Notices

Books, Films, Arts & Education

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Health Care & Environment

03.17 China's 'war against pollution' shows promising results, study finds [U.S. doesn't care]

03.17 China's 'war against pollution' shows promising results, study finds

03.17 In Latest 'Alarming' Attack on Science, Pruitt Reportedly Moving to Restrict Use of Research in EPA Policy [“Stupid is as stupid does.” –Forrest Gump]

03.17 Global energy giants forced to adapt to rise of renewables [the Middle-East's wars may be stupid given looming drop in oil and gas prices]

03.16 The Guardian view on air pollution: moral pusillanimity, political ineptitude

03.16 Pollutionwatch: Cold snap worsens particle load of air

03.16 Energy sector must use new tech to ensure the vulnerable aren't left behind

03.16 Pollution, illness, threats and murder: is this Amazon factory the link?

03.16 It's 50 years since climate change was first seen. Now time is running out

03.15 WHO launches health review after microplastics found in 90% of bottled water [health risks are being assessed]

03.14 World’s great forests could lose half of all wildlife as planet warms – report [ho-hum...]

03.14 Sky-high prices of everything make US healthcare the world's most expensive [legal corruption of government Makes America Less Great Again, and more of a mafia-state]

03.13 Microplastic pollution in oceans is far worse than feared, say scientists

03.13 Krill fishing poses serious threat to Antarctic ecosystem, report warns [What's the cheapest and easiest way to kill all life here? I know, let's...]

03.12 Climate change is a disaster foretold, just like the first world war

03.12 Arizona Utility Opts for Solar and Storage to Meet Peak Demand

News Media Matters

03.15 Verizon Will Fix Broadband Networks, Landlines to Resolve Investigation [Will Trump's judges help or hurt The Public in situations like this?]

Daily: FAIR Blog
The Daily Howler

US Politics, Policy & 'Culture'

03.17 Conditioning Through Contempt: They Are Calling Us Their Base to Demean Us

03.17 Andrew McCabe, ex-FBI deputy and Trump target, fired days before retiring

03.16 Package Bombs Are Killing People in Texas but Donald Trump Hasn’t Said a Thing. There’s a Reason for That.

03.16 N.R.A. Proposes Having Second Armed Teacher in Every Classroom to Stop First Armed Teacher from Misfiring

03.16 Cash in: the rich guys in Trump's cabinet who can't resist public money [morals and rules for behavior are for little people]

03.16 Mueller subpoenas Trump Organization for documents related to Russia – report

03.15 Blasting #BankLobbyistAct, Warren Unveils "The Ending Too Big to Jail Act" to Fight Wall Street Greed

03.15 'Enough': US students come together in spectacular walkout to end gun violence [the world rolls their eyes]

Justice Matters

03.14 Manafort could face ‘rest of life in prison,’ judge says

High Crimes?


Economics, Crony Capitalism

03.17 The Radical Reformist

03.11 Capital Inequity: Conditioned to Accept Collective Enslavement and Self-Nullification

International & Futurism

03.17 Sergei Skripal: Russia expels 23 British diplomats as row deepens

03.17 Turkey claims to have encircled Afrin, besieging up to 200,000 [Kurds are the new Armenians. Is ethnic purity—that DNA testing cannot discern—so important that Turkey and Syria must kill minority ethnic populations?]

03.16 The long read: Vladimir Putin’s politics of eternity

03.16 Australian man who raped Indian orphans released immediately after conviction

03.15 Finland is the happiest country in the world, says UN report

03.15 Busting the Myth of ‘Welfare Makes People Lazy’ [Are all conservative economic theories based on anecdotal gossip of ill-informed, often-biased people? There does seem to be a pattern...]

03.15 Donald Trump admits making up 'facts' in trade meeting with Justin Trudeau [“Stupid is as stupid does.” –Forrest Gump]

03.15 Can we fix it? The repair cafes waging war on throwaway culture

03.15 Spy poisoning: allies back UK and blast Russia at UN security council [videos]

03.14 Rodrigo Duterte to pull Philippines out of international criminal court

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.

You can also mail a check to:
Baltimore News Network, Inc.
P.O. Box 42581
Baltimore, MD 21284-2581
This site Web

Public Service Ads: