Newspaper logo  
  Team Bush Paid Millions to Nathan Sproul--and Tried to Hide It


Team Bush Paid Millions to Nathan Sproul—and Tried to Hide It

by Mark Crispin Miller and Jared Irmas

All the payments by the RNC to Sproul add up to a whopping $8,359,161. Where did all that money come from? Why did the RNC suppress their real expenditures? And what exactly did Sproul do for all that pay?
In the months before the 2004 presidential election, a firm called Sproul & Associates launched voter registration drives in at least eight states, most of them swing states. The group--run by Nathan Sproul, former head of the Arizona Christian Coalition and the Arizona Republican Party--had been hired by the Republican National Committee.

Sproul got into a bit of trouble last fall when, in certain states, it came out that the firm was playing dirty tricks in order to suppress the Democratic vote: concealing their partisan agenda, tricking Democrats into registering as Republicans, surreptitiously re-registering Democrats and Independents as Republicans, and shredding Democratic registration forms.

The scandal got a moderate amount of local coverage in some states--and then the election was over. Now anyone who brought up Nathan Sproul, or any of the other massive crimes and improprieties committed on or prior to Election Day, was shrugged off as a dealer in "conspiracy theory."

It seems that Sproul did quite a lot of work for the Republicans. Exactly how much did he do? More specifically, how much did the RNC pay Sproul & Associates?

If you went online last week to look up how much money Sproul received from the Republicans in 2004, you would have found that, according to the party (whose figures had been posted by the Center for Responsive Politics), the firm was paid $488,957.

In fact, the RNC paid Sproul a great deal more than that. From an independent study of the original data filed by the Republicans with the Federal Election Commission, it is clear that Sproul was paid a staggering $8.3 million for its work against the Democrats.

How the true figures came to be revealed
On Dec. 3, 2004, the Republican National Committee filed their Post-General Report with the FEC, accounting for all expenditures between Oct. 14 and Nov. 22.

Among the Itemized Disbursements there were listed six expenditures to Sproul & Associates, amounting to a total sum of $4.5 million. Three of them were for "Political Consulting," and the other three were for "Voter Registration Costs." The RNC paid Sproul the biggest amount on the day before the election: $1,668,733.

On Jan. 7, 2005 and again on May 3, 2005, the RNC sent in revised reports. Those items were unchanged in all of them.

After they received the RNC's second revised report, the FEC expressed dissatisfaction with the vague phrase "Voter Registration Costs." In a May 18 letter to Michael Retzer, Treasurer of the RNC, the FEC requested that itemized disbursements labeled thus be further clarified.

On June 17, the RNC submitted a (third) revised report. In it, those three suspicious Sproul expenditures labeled "Voter Registration Costs" had been changed to "Political Consulting." As a "clarification," it was as vague as possible. Although it only raised more questions, there seems to be no letter in the FEC database concerning that unedifying correction.

Moreover, there are some big surprises buried in the paperwork. It turned out that the RNC paid Sproul not only for their pre-election work, but also paid them for work after the election. According to their Year-End Report, filed on Jan. 28, 2005, the RNC paid Sproul for "Political Consulting" in December--long after all the voter registration drives had ended.

And two months later, when the RNC filed their amended Year-End Report on May 3, the dates of those December expenditures mysteriously changed. A payment of $210,176, once made on Dec. 20, was changed to Dec. 22. A payment of $344,214, initially recorded on Dec. 22, was changed to Dec. 9.

As to why Sproul was being paid in December, and why the dates were changed, one can only speculate. But it may be worth noting that the Ohio recount took place from Dec. 13 through Dec. 28.

Because these amendments were made in 2005, the Center for Responsive Politics' website mistakenly allocated that money to the 2006 cycle. When we informed them of these missing numbers yesterday, CRP was quick to adjust them. They also included two more expenditures: a $323,907 payment for more "Political Consulting" (10/12/04) and $450,257 for "Mailing Costs" (10/04/04).

And there was more--much more.

Fuzzy math
The documents also suggest that the RNC may have changed the dates of nine payments to suggest expenditures in 2005, thereby shifting focus from the 2004 election.

In going through the documents, CRP located nine expenditures from the future: Sproul somehow received a total of $1,323,154 between Sept. 2 and Sept. 29, 2005. Another $472,642 is hidden in 2005. Four of those prospective items were (or will be) for "Generic Media Buys" or "Lodging, Transportation." The other four are (or will be) for "Voter Registration Efforts"--surely an expense incurred in September of last year, not this year.

Larry Noble, executive director of CRP, considers such future expenditures for, say, "Lodging, Transportation" rather odd, but he gives the RNC the benefit of the doubt. "My guess is that it's an error," he suggests. "It's possible that they're cleaning up voter registration lists in September, but it's also possible they made a mistake."

Even if that mistaken date is just a typo, it is, to say the least, not likely that they made the same mistake in nine uniquely dated items for 2004.

In any case, all the payments by the RNC to Sproul add up to a whopping $8,359,161--making it the RNC's eighth biggest expenditure of the 2004 campaign.

Sproul is currently under investigation by the Oregon Attorney General's office, for altering the voter registration forms of several thousand students in that state. Whether the new numbers are in part mistaken, they represent a huge expense for the Republicans. Given Sproul's history of serious electoral mischief, affecting countless Democratic voters in the last election, it is important that we ask some sober questions: Where did all that money come from? Why did the RNC suppress their real expenditures? And what exactly did Sproul do for all that pay? If we're going to get some reasonable answers, the FEC must undertake a very thorough audit of the books.

Mark Crispin Miller, a professor of culture and communication at New York University, is author of several books, including Boxed In: The Culture of TV, Mad Scientists: The Secret History of Modern Propaganda, The Bush Dyslexicon and Cruel and Unusual: Bush/Cheney's New World Order. Jared Irmas is a junior at New York University. Additional reporting by John Brakey.

Published by the Baltimore Chronicle with permission of the authors. Originally published on Thursday, June 30, 2005 at News From Underground

Copyright © 2005 The Baltimore Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

This story was published on July 5, 2005.

Local News & Opinion

Ref. : Civic Events

Ref. : Arts & Education Events

Ref. : Public Service Notices

Books, Films, Arts & Education

10.06 Teachers vs. Prisons

10.05 The Shame of Yale's Calhoun College

10.05 America Needs to Let Go of Its Reverence for the Bachelor's Degree

10.04 The Joyful, Illiterate Kindergartners of Finland

Open Letters:

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Health Care & Environment

10.06 The 4 Kinds of People Who Don’t Vaccinate Their Kids

10.06 Seven practical steps to protect our cities from the effects of climate change

10.06 Chile to Create One of World’s Largest Marine Parks

10.06 Citigroup Becomes Third Major Bank to Cut Financing to Coal Industry

10.05 A story of hope: the Guardian launches phase II of its climate change campaign

10.05 Climate change is a global problem. Climate action is a local solution

10.05 Think dairy farming is benign? Our rivers tell a different story

10.04 Watch out for the MEGATSUNAMI: Scientists find evidence of 800ft wave caused by a collapsing volcano and say it could happen again

10.04 Most Efficient Commercial Solar Panels In USA To Come From SolarCity?

10.04 Air quality: governments woo the motor industry with dire results [The Big Issue: Letters to The Observer]

10.04 Car emissions test body receives 70% of cash from motor industry [It's the "conservative" model of regulation]

10.04 Right-wing hate can't kill widespread love for Planned Parenthood

News Media Matters

10.04 Robert Reich: The Washington Post’s new attack on Bernie Sanders is bunk

Daily: FAIR Blog
The Daily Howler

US Politics, Policy & 'Culture'

10.06 Stephen Colbert to Donald Trump: ‘There Is Zero Chance’ You’ll Be President [7:58 video]

10.06 Watch John Oliver Explain Broken U.S. Mental Health System [11:54 video]

10.05 Paul Krugman: “The GOP has become fossilized”

10.05 Hillary Clinton unveils plan for tougher checks in bid to reduce gun violence

10.05 Bernie Sanders thrills Boston with call to fight racism and reform gun law

10.03 Oregon shooting occurred in state that 'actually forces colleges to allow guns'

10.03 Oregon shooting: Jeb Bush says 'stuff happens' as left calls for gun control

10.03 Oregon shooting aftermath: eight ways to stop gun massacres in the US

10.03 'Thoughts and prayers are not enough': Why the US has so many mass shootings [Graphic: 994 mass shootings in 1,004 days]

10.03 Obama, Guns, and the Politics of Hopelessness

Justice Matters
High Crimes?

10.06 U.S. General Says Afghans Requested Airstrike That Hit Kunduz Hospital

Economics, Crony Capitalism

10.06 Obama faces TPP deal balancing act as Congress considers approval

10.01 Gauis Publius: What Sanders Can Accomplish by Not Acting

10.01 Toys ‘R’ Us Brings Temporary Foreign Workers to U.S. to Move Jobs Overseas

10.01 How the banks ignored the lessons of the crash [the Long Read]

10.01 Senator Elizabeth Warren to Join Call to Alter Sales of Distressed Loans


10.06 Israel demolishes homes of Palestinian attackers as clashes escalate

10.05 Aided by Climate Change, ISIL wages Water war on Shiites of south Iraq

10.05 Civil War: Israeli troops shoot 96 Palestinians after 4 Israelis Killed

10.05 Binyamin Netanyahu vows 'harsh offensive' on Palestinian violence

10.05 Driverless robot taxis to be tested in Japanese town

10.05 Germany expects up to 1.5 million asylum seekers in 2015, says report

10.04 Nineteen feared dead amid heavy flooding in French Riviera

10.04 Paris’s first attempt at car-free day brings big drop in air and noise pollution

10.04 Inside the Indian village where a mob killed a man for eating beef

10.04 Gulf states plan military response as Putin raises the stakes in Syria

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.

You can also mail a check to:
Baltimore News Network, Inc.
P.O. Box 42581
Baltimore, MD 21284-2581
This site Web

Public Service Ads: