Newspaper logo  
 
 
  ACLU Charges That Government is Abusing 'States Secrets Privilege' to Cover Up National Security Blunders, ACLU Says

NATIONAL NEWS:

ACLU Charges That Government is Abusing "States Secrets Privilege" to Cover Up National Security Blunders, ACLU Says

Source: American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU)

DC Court of Appeals is urged to reinstate the case of former FBI translator Sibel Edmunds.
WASHINGTON, January 12, 2005--The American Civil Liberties Union today urged the D.C. Court of Appeals to reinstate the case of former FBI translator Sibel Edmonds, saying that the government is abusing the "state secrets privilege" to silence employees who expose national security blunders.

"The government should be applauding, not punishing, employees who risk their jobs to expose threats to our nation's security," said ACLU Associate Legal Director Ann Beeson in the ACLU's press release on this matter. "If the lower court ruling stands, many thousands of government employees will be unprotected from retaliatory dismissal, with no recourse in the courts, and others will be even less willing to risk exposing misconduct or corruption."

Edmonds, a former Middle Eastern language specialist hired by the FBI shortly after 9/11, was fired in 2002 after repeatedly reporting serious security breaches and misconduct in the agency's translation program. She challenged her retaliatory dismissal by filing suit in federal court. Last July, the district court dismissed her case when Attorney General John Ashcroft invoked the so-called state secrets privilege. The ACLU is representing Edmonds in the appeal.

The ACLU has announced its willingness to support other national security whistleblowers and has encouraged others to come forward. Notable whistleblowers such as John M. Cole and Frederic Whitehurst support Edmonds' case, as do several senators, the families of 9/11 victims, the Project On Government Oversight and a long list of others. Many of them will be joining a friend-of-the-court brief to be filed later this month. Representatives of these groups will be present at a noon news conference at the National Press Club on Wednesday, January 26.

In its brief, the ACLU sharply criticizes the government's "radical theory" that every aspect of the Edmonds' case involves state secrets and therefore it cannot go forward. In accepting the government's theory, the ACLU said, the district court relied on the government's secret evidence but denied Edmonds the opportunity to prove her case based on non-sensitive evidence. That approach, the ACLU said, "made a mockery of the adversarial process and denied Ms. Edmonds her constitutional right to a day in court."

"As a U.S. citizen, I am disturbed that my government is imposing such severe punishment on truth tellers," Edmonds said in a prepared statement to the press. "I am pursuing this appeal not only on my own behalf but on behalf of government employees everywhere who understand that nothing is more important than protecting our security."

The state secrets privilege, when properly invoked, permits the government to block disclosure of particular documents that would cause harm to national security. In the Edmonds case, the government used the privilege not just to protect particular documents but to urge dismissal of the entire case.

History has shown that the government has relied on the state secrets privilege to cover up its own negligence. In the 1948 Supreme Court case Reynolds v. United States, the government claimed that disclosing a military flight accident report would jeopardize secret military equipment and harm national security. Nearly 50 years later, in 2004, the truth came out--the accident report contained no state secrets, but instead confirmed that the cause of the crash was faulty maintenance of the B-29 fleet.

The government is engaged in a similar cover-up in the Edmonds case, the ACLU said. In 2002, at the request of Senate Judiciary Committee members Charles Grassley (R-IA) and Patrick Leahy (D-VT), the FBI provided several unclassified briefings to Members of Congress in which it confirmed many of Edmonds' allegations.

More than two years later, the Justice Department retroactively classified those briefings, which were reported in the Congressional Record, and asked Members who had the information posted on their web sites to remove certain documents. The ACLU said the move was a "blatant attempt to bolster the government's efforts to dismiss Edmonds' case on state secrets grounds." The retroactive classification has also been challenged in a separate lawsuit brought by the Project On Government Oversight.

Only two weeks after the district court dismissed Edmonds' case, FBI director Robert Mueller wrote a letter to Senator Grassley reporting that the Department of Justice Inspector General had completed a classified investigation and concluded that Edmonds' allegations "were at least a contributing factor in why the FBI terminated her services."

Later this week, in response to a separate Freedom of Information Act lawsuit, the Inspector General is expected to release an unclassified version of the report's executive summary. The rest of the report will remain classified.

Oral argument in Edmonds' case' is scheduled for April 21, 2005. Ann Beeson will be arguing on behalf of Edmonds. Co-counsel in the case are: Melissa Goodman and Benjamin Wizner of the national ACLU; Art Spitzer of the ACLU of the National Capital Area; Mark Zaid of the Washington law firm Krieger and Zaid; and Eric Seiff of New York.




Copyright © 2005 The Baltimore Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

This story was published on January 15, 2005.

 
Local Stories, Events

Ref. : Civic Events

Ref. : Arts & Education Events

Ref. : Public Service Notices

Books, Films, Arts & Education
Letters

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Health Care & Environment

06.22 'Washing is a privilege': life on the frontline of India's water crisis

06.21 China Just Handed the World a 111-Million-Ton Trash Problem [we must switch to bioplastics ASAP]

06.21 Some rare good climate news: the fossil fuel industry is weaker than ever

06.20 ALEC’s Deadly Asbestos Agenda Benefits Koch Industries, Nationwide [the sociopaths are at it again]

06.18 Flooding from sea level rise threatens over 300,000 US coastal homes – study

06.16 Delhi's air pollution is now so bad it is literally off the chart [an increasingly deadly problem]

06.16 Former Bank of Canada Head: Pipeline Protesters May Be Killed. So Be It.

06.15 What if Canada had backed wind energy instead of the oil sands? [infographic]

06.14 The rate of Antarctic melting has nearly tripled in the past five years

06.14 The legal fight to leave the dirtiest fossil fuels in the ground

06.12 Our plastic pollution crisis is too big for recycling to fix

06.12 Giant African baobab trees die suddenly after thousands of years

News Media Matters

Daily: FAIR Blog
The Daily Howler

US Politics, Policy & 'Culture'

06.23 Recognizing the Neoliberal Roots at the Heart of Trump's Cruel and Inhumane Border Policies

06.23 National Suicide Point?

06.22 As 'Wealthiest and Freest Country in the World,' Nikki Haley Tells Bernie Sanders It's 'Ridiculous' to Examine US Poverty [how underregulated capitalism kills people and entire nations]

06.22 50 Years Later, We Still Have a Dream [how underregulated capitalism kills people and entire nations]

06.21 Migrants in Detention Are Suffering Widespread Abuse and Neglect

06.21 James Comey: 'You stare at children crying – what kind of people are we?’ [We have stupidly allowed bribery and greed to corrupt government to the point where morality—and what's best for people is totally ignored...is considered too late.]

Justice Matters
High Crimes?

06.23 Gang raped and set on fire: ICC pushes to investigate Myanmar Rohingya atrocities

06.17 Coalition Ignores Famine Warnings and Continues Assault on Yemen as Critics Question US Complicity [BARBARISM]

Economics, Crony Capitalism

06.22 The Unsurpassed Power Trip by an Insuperable Control Freak: An Open Letter to Jeff Bezos [how underregulated capitalism kills people and entire nations]

06.19 'CEOs don't want this released': US study lays bare extreme pay-ratio problem

06.16 As AT&T-Time Warner Close Deal, Floodgates 'Wide Open' for Corporate Mega-Mergers

06.16 Social mobility in richest countries 'has stalled since 1990s'

International & Futurism

06.23 World to Refugees: Go to Hell

06.23 Top Six Dictators who also Divided Children from Parents like Trump/Sessions [joining the Elite Sociopaths Club]

06.23 North Korea Agreed to Denuclearize, But US Refuses Despite Treaty Obligation

06.23 The Billionaire Class is Not Fit to Rule – Paul Jay [14:31 video]

06.22 SHE NAMED HER CHILD “ENOUGH”

06.22 Europe’s democrats must unite to prevent a far-right takeover [how underregulated capitalism kills people and entire nations]

06.21 Trump’s Astonishing Reversal Is No Solution

06.21 Basic income could work—if you do it Canada-style

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.

You can also mail a check to:
Baltimore News Network, Inc.
P.O. Box 42581
Baltimore, MD 21284-2581
Google
This site Web

Public Service Ads: