Newspaper logo  
 
 
  Beware the Heroes of the Left

MEDIA CRITICISM:

Beware the Heroes of the Left

by Scott Loughrey

If Michael Moore, Richard Clarke, Ray McGovern, Scott Ritter, Sibel Edmonds and Amy Goodman were to meet at a tea-party, what would they discuss? Each arguably is working in some capacity to uphold the propaganda of the State.
June 14, 2004--The last time that Amy Goodman had Sibel Edmonds on her show "Democracy Now!," it was a friendly (and extended) chat between the two women in DN's curmudgeonly firehouse studio. Goodman and many others have consistently identified Edmonds as a 9-11 "whistle-blower."

Edmonds, a former FBI translator, claims to have seen documents warning that al Qaeda would attack the World Trade Center using hijacked airplanes. Notice that her position directly corresponds with the Bush Regime's official story that they were merely negligent over the events of 9-11. It is the sign of a very dark era that a person whose story is actually repeating the propaganda of the state is widely being given the stature of a legitimate whistle-blower like Daniel Ellsberg.

A particularly surreal part of the segment between Goodman and Edmonds comes at the end. Goodman gently asks Edmonds whether she is "afraid." Edmonds pauses and one can feel Goodman's sycophantic question hanging in the air. It is moments like this that make many wonder about Goodman's persistent defense of the official story of 9-11. Goodman has had at least five advocates of the official story on her program for lengthy interviews featuring softball questions. Meanwhile, the one person so far permitted to dispute the official story on Democracy Now was treated with obvious contempt.

Another person besides Edmonds whose views on 9-11 are being given significant exposure by the neoliberal media is Scott Ritter. Regard his recent commentary about the CIA. Ritter tells us that the CIA has a reputation that could be damaged if the top guy suddenly left. More crucially, Ritter also informs us that 9-11 was an "intelligence failure" for the CIA.

It seems curious that this very tough ex-Marine is defending the CIA's reputation so vigorously. After all, in the last few years Ritter has earned a reputation for being the Bush Regime's most formidable opponent to their unlawful invasion of Iraq, garnering a lot of exposure from the established left media in the process. Ritter has already enthralled anti-war audiences everywhere with his opposition to the idea of the Bush Regime manufacturing evidence about Iraq's weapons capabilities in order to start an unnecessary war. It seems very inconsistent that the year following this campaign he is now vociferously defending the CIA's reputation. Also, as a leading opposition figure of the Bush Regime he might act like he was somewhat concerned about the suspicious circumstances of Paul Wellstone's plane crash. Instead, Ritter's tone of voice reflects very strong solidarity with the Agency.

In books written by fiction writers Graham Greene and John Le Carré, spies can never leave their business once inside. In contrast, notice Ritter's statement that he "was an intelligence officer for many years?"

What could Greene or Le Carré write after reading a sentence like that? They might write a story where a charismatic, tough-talking ex-Marine infiltrated a large anti-war movement by posing as a leading opposition figure to a criminal invasion of a sovereign nation. With the anti-war movement successfully infiltrated he proceeds to betray his new friends by echoing the state's propaganda over its true role with the day of terrorism which directly led to aggression by the Empire.

Greene and Le Carré also come to my mind every time that Ray McGovern is heard from. McGovern is represented as an ex-CIA man (with 27 years of experience) by the established left media. Like Ritter, McGovern also earned his connection with the anti-war movement by opposing the criminal Iraq war. Naturally, "Democracy Now" invites McGovern on regularly. McGovern certainly is immediately likable on the radio. With his soothing, paternal voice he freely mentions that he used to provide in-person intelligence briefings to the first President Bush. Yet, with each appearance on "Democracy Now" and with every new article he writes, McGovern makes sure to confirm some aspect of the Bush Regime's official story of 9-11. Like Ritter, he's also functioning to promote the CIA as a respectable institution to the anti-war movement.

Richard Clarke is another figure with a questionable identity. Clarke is described as a "defector" from the White House. Like everyone else mentioned so far, Clarke's view is that the Bush Regime is only negligent over 9-11. Clarke's book about his experiences in the White House was curiously timed for publication only a few months before the 9-11 Commission was reaching a climax. When the latter hearings were under way, Amy Goodman hosted Clarke twice for easy, extended interviews. While members of the 9-11 Truth Movement were begging her to invite a 9-11 skeptic on her show, Amy icily maintained Clarke as the outer limit of permissible dialogue during the height of the 9-11 Commission hearings.

Then there is Michael Moore. His new film, "Fareinheit 911," reiterates the propaganda that there were 19 hijackers on 9/11/01 and 15 of them were Saudis. However, what is really revealing about Moore is his amazing claim to have met and videotaped recent decapitation-victim Nick Berg. One would think there were a few degrees of separation between them. Moore is one of this country's most famous filmmakers. At the same time, the Berg video has been declared a fraud around the world. It seems incredible that Moore managed to videotape the one guy in this country who would later be seen being killed in a clearly fraudulent video that many suspect was a botched PsyOps campaign by the Regime. Personally, I don't believe Moore for a minute.

If Michael Moore, Richard Clarke, Ray McGovern, Scott Ritter, Sibel Edmonds and Amy Goodman were to meet at a tea-party, what would they discuss? Each arguably is working in some capacity to uphold the propaganda of the State. In my (unprofessional) opinion it is very dangerous for the anti-war movement to continue accepting this particular group as allies in the struggle to stop the Bush Regime.


Scott Loughrey, of Baltimore, frequently writes critical assessments of the media. For more of his work, visit media-criticism.com.


Copyright © 2004 The Baltimore Chronicle. All rights reserved.

Republication or redistribution of Baltimore Chronicle content is expressly prohibited without their prior written consent.

This story was published on June 14, 2004.
 
Bookmark and Share
Local News & Opinion

01.26 Local Democrats Invited to Brainstorming Session on Sun., Jan. 31

Ref. : Local Newsbriefs

Travel
Books, Films, Arts & Education

02.04 'The Power of Nightmares': Underwear vs. Reason

Letters

Ref. : Letters to the editor

Open Letters:
Health & Environment

Video National Health Care Systems In Other Countries

02.09 States Launch their Own Health Care reforms

02.03 States Face Worsening Recession with Health Care Funds on the Chopping Block

01.18 Drugmaker Got Kickbacks for Nursing Home Patients

Media Watching

02.04 Err-America

02.03 The Right Gets Itself 'Wired'

Ref. : The Daily Howler

Legal Matters

01.25 Thinking About Fictions

01.24 US Democracy's End of the Road

01.22 Editorial: U.S. Supreme Court Nails Down the Coffin of Democracy

01.22 Security Fools

US Politics, Policy & Culture

02.09 Palin, Psy-Ops & 'Condescending' Libs

02.09 Growing Hunger in America

02.08 The US Government has Lost its Reason for Being

02.08 Thinking About Oracles

02.06 No Direction Home: Pakistan and the Imperial Principle

02.04 Howard Zinn and the State of the Union

02.04 The US Supreme Court: Vanguard of Friendly American Fascism?

02.04 The New War Against Money

02.04 David Brooks Goes After Greedy Geezers

02.02 Obama's Budget Ducks Pentagon Cuts

02.02 Budgets, War and Blind Ambition: The Limited Minds of the American Elite

02.01 Thinking About Definitives

02.01 Remembering Howard Zinn (1922 - 2010)

01.29 American History 101: We Are Devo

01.29 Obama's Outreach to Americans: Empty Rhetoric, Business As Usual

01.28 The Supreme Court's Partisanship

01.27 Freeze Frame: Flopsweat and Farce in the Hollow Halls of Power

01.25 Granny D on Campaign Finance Reform

01.25 S.C. Republican’s Plan: Starve the Poor So They’ll Stop “Breeding”

01.23 It's Time for Kucinich, Conyers, Feingold and Other `Progressives' in Congress to Take a Stand

01.21 Massachusetts' Message of Stupid

01.21 Terrorism Defined: Bill Clinton Lights Our Way to Truth

01.21 How Obama Lost His Way

01.21 Political Earthquake Rocks Massachusetts

01.20 Obama Cuts Deal that Will Reduce Social Security, Medicare and all Entitlements

01.20 Critical Mass: Dem Agenda Opens Right-Wing Doors

01.19 Outsourcing War: The Rise of Private Military Contractors

“High Crimes?”

01.25 The Silence and the Shield: Depraved Indifference to the Atrocities of Power

01.19 Dark as a Dungeon: A Brutal System Stripped Bare

Economics & Business Non/Mis/Malfeasance

02.07 AIG-Gate: The World's Greatest Insurance Heist

02.06 The Free Market Fetish

02.04 The Crisis is Not Over

02.03 States Face Worsening Recession with Health Care Funds on the Chopping Block

02.02 Rule by the Rich

01.29 The Battle of the Titans: JPMorgan vs. Goldman Sachs

01.27 State of the Union: Obama’s “Automatic IRA” Plan Could Make Bush’s Wildest Dreams Come True

01.26 Obama, Read Your Reagan on Capital Gains Taxation

01.24 Funding Public Health Care with a Publicly-Owned Bank: How Canada Did It

01.18 Thinking About Accelerants

International

02.08 Aafia Siddiqui: Victimized by American Injustic

02.07 Annals of Liberation: Obama Surge Driving Thousands From Their Homes

02.05 Human Rights Abuses in Israel and Occupied Palestine

02.03 Child Slavery in Haiti

01.30 Blood is His Argument: Tony Blair's Gentle Cuddling at Iraq "Inquiry"

01.28 Obama Ignores Key Afghan Warning

01.27 Haiti's Earthquake: Natural or Engineered

01.26 Helping Haiti’s Elders

01.26 Focus on Israel: Harvesting Haitian Organs

01.25 Focus on Haiti: Washington's Militarized Takeover

01.22 The Lessons of Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions

01.18 Disaster Capitalism Headed to Haiti

We are a non-profit Internet-only newspaper publication founded in 1973. Your donation is essential to our survival.
Google
This site Web

Public Service Ads:
Verifiable Voting in Maryland